Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
JMU | Wellness > Health

The Gym Isn’t as Judgy as You Think: How to Combat Gym Anxiety

Caroline Becker Student Contributor, James Madison University
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at JMU chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

The words, “I’m scared to go to the gym,” always hurt my heart a little every time I hear them. As fitness has become more popular over the past few years, so has gym anxiety.

University of Rochester Medicine defines gym anxiety as “feelings of fear, self-consciousness, or intimidation that can cause people to avoid gyms altogether.” It can include feeling like you don’t know what you’re doing, comparing your progress or appearance to others, and becoming hyper-aware of your movements or body.

The rise of gym anxiety has almost been like a domino effect. Digital fitness culture has exploded, and there are trends in every direction: bulking, cutting, Pilates, the StairMaster, lifting heavy, and influencers making blanket statements about what a “real” workout is. More people are going to the gym because it feels like that’s what’s expected now. As gyms become more crowded, opportunities for social comparison increase, and that makes self-consciousness even worse.

People with gym anxiety often believe everyone is watching or judging them while they work out. In reality, that thought is usually much louder in your own head than it is anywhere else. But it’s overly optimistic to tell someone, “Nobody cares what you’re doing,” and expect that to magically erase their anxiety.

So instead of oversimplifying the issue, here are my tips for managing gym anxiety.

Recognize the intrinsic benefits of working out

Something I learned in my Group Exercise prep course while training to become an instructor was the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation comes from genuine joy and personal satisfaction, while extrinsic motivation comes from external rewards or pressures.

Exercise on the internet has pushed extrinsic motivation to the forefront, leading people to believe working out is purely about losing weight, looking good, or achieving a certain body. That mindset has made exercise feel much more intimidating, and in turn has made people more nervous to step into the gym.

Instead, try recognizing some intrinsic benefits. Maybe you genuinely enjoy the movements you’re doing. Maybe you love the challenge of the workout. Maybe it makes you feel proud to finish a workout and accomplish something. It’s okay to start with an external goal like weight loss or mood regulation, but extrinsic motivation alone usually won’t keep you going. The habit sticks when you combine it with something you actually enjoy.

Gradually Expose Yourself

It’s easy to walk into the gym for the first time and feel like you have to jump right in: lift the heaviest weight you can, do an hour on the StairMaster, or stay for as long as possible.

That’s actually one of the quickest ways to burn yourself out.

Instead, start simple. Try a 15–20 minute workout to ease yourself in. Go to the multipurpose room and experiment with lighter dumbbells, test out a few exercises, or walk on the treadmill for a bit. Even completing one successful workout can make the next visit feel much less intimidating. As time goes on, you can gradually build up both the length and complexity of your workouts.

Try Starting with Cardio

Some people get to the gym and immediately hop on a weight machine. Others find it helpful to begin with cardio, like a treadmill walk, jog, or StairMaster session.

If lifting is your long-term goal, starting with 10–15 minutes of cardio can still be a great idea, especially when you’re new. It helps warm you up, gives you time to settle your nerves, and lets you observe the space around you. You can look at different equipment, watch how people perform certain exercises, and even scan the QR codes that many machines have for video demonstrations.

Go with a friend

If you’re nervous about what strangers think of you at the gym, it definitely doesn’t hurt to bring someone you’re comfortable with.

Ask a friend if they want to work out with you. It could be someone experienced or someone trying the gym for the first time too. Either way, having a familiar face can reduce anxiety, distract you from self-conscious thoughts, and help keep you accountable.

UnitedHealthcare says, “if a workout partner is counting on you to show up at the gym, you may be more likely to go.”

And from someone on the other side, it’s genuinely one of my favorite things when a friend tells me they want to become more comfortable in the gym and I get to help. They almost always leave feeling so much more confident than when they walked in.

Make a playlist and bring headphones

Music can make a huge difference in making the gym feel less nerve-wracking. Honestly, as someone who goes to the gym regularly, working out is so much less fun without it, whether I’m lifting or doing cardio.

Make a playlist filled with your favorite songs and let that become part of your routine. And it doesn’t have to be hip-hop or high-energy workout music. I usually listen to pop, but I have one friend who listens to screamo and another who listens to classical music. There isn’t a “right” genre—it’s whatever makes you feel the most comfortable and helps you enjoy being there.

The gym can feel intimidating, and for a lot of people, that’s a scary thing to even admit. But now more than ever, that feeling is very common and very valid. Everyone starts somewhere, and the hardest part is simply showing up. You don’t have to have perfect form, the perfect workout split, or know every exercise. And you definitely don’t have to look or dress a certain way to belong there. Just remember: when you go to the gym to exercise, you’re doing it for yourself, not for anyone else.

Caroline is a junior Communications Studies major at JMU with a PR concentration and a minor in political science. In her free time, she enjoys spending time with friends, running, or trying out a new fitness class. This is her second year writing for HerCampus. She loves the community of girls she writes with and being able to write about all things, whether it's current events, fitness, or personal experiences!