Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo

Worthwhile Changes in a Tale as Old as Time

Kyla Buenaventura Student Contributor, California Lutheran University
Cal Lutheran Contributor Student Contributor, California Lutheran University
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at Cal Lutheran chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

For those who have watched the new live action Beauty and the Beast, you may have noticed some differences between the live action version and the animated version. For those who have read the original literary works, you’ll notice that Disney brought back some aspects of the story and incorporated them into the newly released film. Here are 10 changes I saw in Beauty and the Beast and why I liked them!

1.) Belle was not just portrayed as someone who read books! Her love for learning and intellect was showcased through the ways in which she combined her creativity and knowledge to make her life easier. Case in point, Belle used a big barrel to create an ingenious and infinitely more efficient way of doing laundry, rather than handwashing every article of clothing. By putting soap in the barrel and attaching it to her horse while the horse walked around the well, the barrel would rotate and have the same effect as a washing machine. Additionally, instead of sitting hopelessly in her new room, Belle used the clothes from the singer turned wardrobe, Madame Garderobe, to create a rope to escape through the window in her tower.

2.) Belle’s passion for reading and her need to help others learn was also more evident in the live action film. She encouraged a young girl to read with her when she noticed the young girl’s curiosity and praised her when she successfully read a sentence. Belle’s independent and sassy attitude was also shown when Belle stood up for herself and the young girl, when she questioned why the town had an issue with having more than one literate female.

3.) Beast has a personality! He’s more than just a terrifyingly brutish monster or a lovestruck, compassionate gentleman. He has a sense of humor and the live action film also portrays some of the characteristics from the original literary works. For example in the original literary works, Beast was depicted to be a fellow intellectual and part of the reason as to why he and Belle bonded over time was through their mutual love of learning. In the live action film, Beast made a nonchalant comment about reading all the books in his library, except the ones written in Greek, and had a discussion with Belle about their favorite Shakespearean plays.

4.) In the animated version, LeFou is a simple minded minion that Gaston can easily step all over. However, LeFou in live action has a personalty that added more to the story. He questioned Gaston and knew some of Gaston’s ideals and acts were wrong. He’s also witty; when Gaston declares that he’ll marry Belle, LeFou subtly states that all Gaston has to offer in a relationship is his “athletic inclination.” I think several audience members, especially younger audience members, can sympathize with LeFou when he refuses to admit that Gaston left Maurice, literally, to the wolves. When you’re being pressured by someone who not only has an enormous amount of power in the place you live, but you also thought of as a friend, you become inclined to help them out, regardless of what’s right.

5.) The background information about Belle’s mother and Belle and the Beast’s trip to Paris was enlightening. We finally find out what happens to Belle’s mom and why she and Maurice had to move to the small, provincial town! Of course it broke hearts everywhere to learn that Belle’s mother died because of the plague. Belle’s love for roses is also explained when it’s shown that one of the keepsakes Belle and Maurice remembered from the time her mother was alive, regardless of the fact that Belle was a baby, was the little rose rattle.

6.) They brought back the real reason as to why the Beast imprisoned Maurice. According to the original written works, Belle asked for a rose as a souvenir from her father’s trip; when Maurice was about to leave the castle to go back home, he stole a rose from the Beast’s garden. In the written works, the Beast, although hidden, allowed Maurice to stay in the castle and made sure to give him food and a comfortable place to rest. After his hospitality, the mere act of attempting to steal from the castle infuriated the beast, especially because we know how important roses are to the Beast. The live action film adopted the same sequence of events: Belle’s request for a rose, Maurice getting lost, Maurice staying in the castle, Maurice taking a rose, and Beast getting angry and imprisoning him.

7.) The new songs that were included! My personal favorite was Beast’s solo “Evermore,” which he sang after he encouraged Belle to help her father. The song has hints from the Broadway version of Beauty and the Beast, “If I Can’t Love Her” and showed just how much the Beast loves Belle. Regardless of the fact that she’s leaving him, for what he thought was forever, and the sadness and pain he feels because he just sentenced himself and the rest of the castle residents to be inanimate, inhumane objects, he still doesn’t regret meeting her and falling in love with her. Thank you Dan Stevens!

8.) How they showed why Beast was such a jerk! Realizing that his mother, who he loved dearly, died when he was young was heartbreaking. His callousness and lack of empathy makes more sense; he wasn’t just a spoiled, bratty prince. His father, who was the original cold-hearted, shallow jerk was the one who influenced the Beast. In result, the young, impressionable, angry prince decided to follow in his father’s footsteps. Now both Belle and Beast’s backstory have been established.

9.) The new couples that were revealed! Unlike the animated film, there was actually a Mr. Potts. One of the interesting aspects of the live action film was in the beginning scene, during  “Belle”, and one of the villagers says that he’s missing something he just can’t remember what that something is. At the end of the film, after the transformations, the same villager who can’t remember what he’s missing is reunited with Mrs. Potts and Chip. In addition, there were also two different interracial couples which hadn’t been shown in a Disney film yet.

10.) The other furniture had more significant roles in this film! Maestro Cadenza added even more humor to the story as well as a different emotional factor because of how he and his beloved wife and partner, Madame Garderobe, are separated and their only reuniting moment is seconds before they become inanimate. Although the butler didn’t have any lines, when the furniture start to become inanimate the butler saves Chip from, literally falling to his death, which pulls at any Disney fans’ heartstrings.

Kyla Buenaventura

Cal Lutheran '19

Kyla Buenaventura was the Writing Director and Senior Editor for Her Campus at Cal Lutheran from 2017-2019. She double majored in Economics and Political Science with an emphasis in Law and Public Policy. When she was still at Cal Lutheran, she loved writing and inspiring her Writing Team to express their love and passion for topics through their own unique writing styles. 
Follow us at HCCallutheran on Twitter, Instagram, Snapchat, and Facebook!