Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
Culture > Entertainment

Maybe The Real ‘TSITP’ Love Story Is Jeremiah & The Mirror Glaze Cake

For years, fans of The Summer I Turned Pretty have been divided into Team Jeremiah or Team Conrad. But after Episode 5? Move over, Bonrad and Jelly shippers — there’s a new couple that fans are invested in: Jeremiah and that damn mirror glaze cake. And in true internet fashion, fans are flooding social media with absolutely unhinged edits and memes. (As a Bonrad truther, I’m here for it.) Spoiler alert: Spoilers for TSITP Season 3 ahead.

For those of you not caught up on TSITP: 1) What are you waiting for? and 2) I’ll catch you up to speed. Episode 5 was the first-ever episode from Conrad’s POV, and we spent a day with Belly and Conrad as they prepared for Belly’s wedding to Jeremiah. It was full of swoon-worthy moments that had me, a 25-year-old woman, practically foaming at the mouth over a fictional character. But between the romantic peach scene and that bedroom moment between Conrad and Belly, there was another scene that stole the show — and it featured Jeremiah whining about a mirror glaze cake for the wedding. Oh, brother.

To give you some context, Jeremiah told Belly that his “one thing” for the wedding was (and I quote) a “two-tier dark chocolate cake with a raspberry coulis filling and a mirror glaze on top.” But after she goes to the bakery, Belly finds out that the cake will cost them $750 — which is not only out of their price range, but is more than what Jeremiah spent on Belly’s engagement ring.

When Belly offers a more reasonable alternative to Jeremiah (a sheet cake with milk chocolate and raspberry, which sounds fire), he pretty much crashes out, lectures her about cacao, and throws a whole hissy fit, saying “Belly, cacao is the bean — it’s what chocolate is made of. Look, the whole flavor profile depends on the bitterness of the dark chocolate and the sweet tartness of the raspberry.” Damn, OK, Willy Wonka.

the mirror glaze cake meme is all over tsitp-Tok

Jeremiah’s fit — which was more passionate than his proposal to Belly, mind you — has taken on a life of its own on social media through unhinged ship edits. IDK about you, but I can’t stop laughing.

@chrisdaddywood

him and that fuckass mirror glaze cake #thesummeriturnedpretty episode 5

♬ son original – L&C

NGL, I’m getting emotional.

This next one has me scared, though.

@od3l3

a case that didn’t sit right with me // not my usual content but this was too funny 😭 #teamconrad #bellyconklin #conradfisher #jeremiahfisher #tsitp #thesummeriturnedpretty #tsitpedit #viral #fyp #foryou #edit #fakeeverything #jeremiahfisheredit #ethelcain conrad belly jeremiah tsitp season 3 episode 5

♬ original sound – ⋆˚✿˖°

It’s not just TikTok, though. X users are also joining in on the fun.

Honestly, I ship it.

Julianna Marie is the Wellness Editor at Her Campus — leading the site's coverage of health, wellness, sex, relationships, and mental health. Additionally, she oversees our College Try franchise, the LGBTQIA+ vertical (Free To Be) and occasionally covers astrology, entertainment, fashion and beauty, and internet culture.

Julianna's work as a screenwriter and filmmaker has also received recognition at major film festivals such as LA Shorts, Tokyo International Film Festival, the NYC Horror Film Festival, and more. Currently, she is in the process of writing her debut novel.

She graduated with a B.F.A in Screenwriting from Chapman University's Dodge College of Film and Media Arts in May 2022, where she formed very strong opinions on movies and a love for the beach. (She's a Pisces.)

When she's not writing burning hot takes and writing about her personal life for the masses (sorry, mom), you can find Julianna cooking, going out with the girls, doing yoga the morning after going out with the girls, watching reality television with her fiancé, playing chess, or advocating for the food scene in Pittsburgh, PA. It really is that good, BTW.

If you like blurry Instagram Stories and food reviews, you can follow her on Instagram at @juliannammarie.