Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
Texas | Culture

Whatever Happened to Being Cringe?

Shreya Dinesh Student Contributor, University of Texas - Austin
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at Texas chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

Justice is gone from the mall. Sephora is full of 10-year-olds. Somewhere along the way, we lost the plot for the awkward phase we thought every young girl once had.

There was once a time when being a tween meant owning at least one sequin shirt that flipped into two different patterns, begging your mom for a trip to Justice, and believing that a pair of neon unicorn leggings could drastically change your life. 

Our bedrooms weren’t put together. Our accessories clashed with our outfits. I know I rocked my side ponytail in confidence … 

We had favorite YouTubers whose makeup and slime tutorials we attempted with absolutely no idea what we were doing. 

And that was the point.

Today, the tween experience only becomes more and more unfamiliar. Justice closed down its stores in 2020 and the world of tween mall shopping has changed entirely. The stores that once gave girls the space to linger after childhood and before adolescence have faded from today’s cultural landscape.

The strangest part is not that these stores are disappearing, but that the stage of life they represent is disappearing along with them.

What happened to the modern-day tween?

The tween years were once a strange yet exciting in-between stage. You were too old for the toys you adored as a little girl, but not old enough to deal with the lifestyle of a teenager just yet. You experimented through clothes, music, and bedroom decor (like the teal walls we were ALL victims of in 2016).

Stores for tweens made this awkward transition feel like its own admirable and remarkable chapter. Their clothes were colorful, over the top, and amazingly ridiculous. Everything sparkled, and everything had a cheesy slogan. There was no pressure to look “effortless” or “chic.”

Then came social media. The distinction between being a kid and being a teenager began to blur, and the tween phase faded along with it. 

A 10-year-old today encounters the same beauty influencers, fashion trends, and lifestyle content as a teenager, and even 20-year-olds. I remember looking up to the older girls at school; I can’t even imagine looking up to thousands of strangers who seem to have perfect lives and appearances. 

Elaborate skincare routines and short-lived, trending viral aesthetics are only increasing the pressure to look older and more polished. Growing up, something we were once supposed to cherish at every stage is now seen as something to optimize to get to the next stage of life. 

The clean girl aesthetic

The difference between the Justice girl and the modern clean girl is more than just a change in fashion.

The Justice girl could wear mismatched accessories, experiment with loud colors that definitely didn’t go together, and embrace an aesthetic that made absolutely no sense. Her style was an expression of something she truly liked, not something she wore to fit in with everyone else. 

Today’s beauty trends dictate a certain set of expectations: the correct skincare routine, perfect hair, popular clothes, and a trending body type. Even looking “natural” is a whole elaborate process. No one “wakes up like this,” but many young girls feel susceptible to the pressure of looking effortlessly beautiful, when that “effortlessness” takes hours of work and lots of money.

Don’t get me wrong, there’s definitely nothing wrong with makeup or wanting to relate to the girls around you. However, it becomes an issue when products targeting young girls are tied to different insecurities. It becomes difficult to differentiate whether you’re experimenting with your identity or trying to correct yourself.

The fear of being cringe

I believe the greatest shift is our willingness to be openly embarrassed.

To be cringe is to care, to try, or to enjoy something without worrying about who approves. It’s singing your favorite song at the top of your lungs (mine is “Heart Attack” by Demi Lovato), wearing an outfit you feel confident in, or being unapologetically obsessed with something no one else understands. 

This freedom is especially hard for girls to maintain. Young girls aren’t only navigating their identity in an increasingly watchful society; they are also discovering societal expectations about what it means to be a woman. We learn to be likable without being “too much,” ambitious without being a threat, and feminine without “asking for it” or trying too hard. 

Not only that, but social media adds an additional layer. It adds the scary thought that any embarrassing moment can be recorded, shared, and judged by someone who would’ve never seen it in the first place. 

When we become too concerned with how we are perceived by others, we stop experimenting. Where’s the fun in that? We avoid interests that might seem uncool, we lose our creativity, and we all become the same person. We alter ourselves before we have the chance to even figure out who we are. 

Girls today aren’t any less playful or creative; they are growing up in a hyper-homogenized culture that gives them more reasons to be self-conscious. 

Let girls be girls!! 

Tweenhood has not disappeared. It literally can’t; we were all 12 at one point, and girls today will still experience being 12. Children still experiment, play, and discover what they love. However, the cultural and public space for doing those things without the pressure to look a certain way requires more attention. 

Maybe we can’t bring back every mall trip, sequin flip shirt, or the moment of finding the perfect quirky earrings in the mirror at Claire’s, but we can bring back what those things once represented. 

We can let girls enjoy things without asking whether they are fashionable or trendy. We can and should encourage hobbies that do not need to become content and interests that define them in the future. There should be room to make mistakes, try on a silly outfit, and look back on it years later with affection instead of shame. 

Hi! My name is Shreya Dinesh, and I'm a nursing major at UT Austin! I love traveling, reading, going on long walks, listening to music, and crocheting! I am always looking for ways to stay connected to the world around me, and reading and writing is a huge part of that! I am so excited to share my thoughts with y'all!