Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
Pitt | Culture > Entertainment

The Christmas Movies You Need To Watch: A Comprehensive Guide

Vera Singh Student Contributor, University of Pittsburgh
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at Pitt chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

Every holiday season, almost everyone pulls out (streams) the Christmas movies, and it’s about that time now, so I figured I should make a list of movies you should definitely watch. These are my personal, quite secular favorites, and they may be removed from the origins of the holiday. But as a non-Christian, I have more Christmas spirit than most people I know, so my opinions are right and qualified. 

Starting off with my absolute favorite Christmas movie and one of my overall best movies of all time, we have It’s a Wonderful Life (1946). If you love classics and the transatlantic accent, you’re almost guaranteed to love this movie. And if you prefer more modern movies, I still highly recommend it!

Why? Because this movie is one of the most magical movies to be made with the fewest visual effects possible. It’s about a hardworking, brilliant man named George Bailey who, despite many opportunities to get rich and improve his family’s life, chooses to help people buy affordable houses with his small loan business, sometimes even at a loss.

Unfortunately, his villain/rival, Mr. Potter from the bank, is one of the meanest people in town, a member of the 1%, and is determined to do everything to stop George. One night, after one of Mr. Potter’s schemes, George is nearly driven to suicide. But he really is a good man, and his guardian angel has other plans for him. 

I love this movie because it reminds us to be grateful for the little parts of life that go unappreciated. I love that George’s guardian angel doesn’t have a magical fix for all his problems, nor does he give him a motivational speech. He just shows him what the world would be like without George, and it’s a really powerful message.

Also, there are definitely some implications in terms of Mr. Potter’s narrow control of most of the wealth and how it affects their community; this film applies to conversations we should be having about the US right now.

It certainly has a bit of a religious undertone with the angels, anti-suicide values, and God as stars that talk in a few scenes (it’s not as crazy as it sounds), but it’s far more of a Christmas movie than one motivated by Christianity. It’s super duper cute, and you get that warm, fuzzy feeling many times throughout the film, especially at the end.

Next, we have Elf (2003). If you don’t find this movie funny, I don’t trust you. You might just be hating to hate. This is the first movie I watch every year to kickstart the holiday movie marathon, and it’s the lightest one that gets you all holly and jolly.

If you don’t know, this is about a human who is raised as an elf in the North Pole. But you do, so go watch it!

Next, we have Home Alone (1990) and Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992). Again, you know this one.

A toss-up here is The Guardians of the Galaxy Holiday Special (2022). If you’re a Marvel character fan and don’t need a deep story to enjoy a movie, this is a fun quick watch. Only 42 minutes long, this is like a filler episode in the Guardians saga that’s surprisingly charming. 

My next hard-hitter on this list is A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965)! Less of a movie because it is a half-hour television special, but it deserves the attention a movie does. It has not only simple animation and an innocent story, but also an amazing jazzy soundtrack. You have to watch it, if just to see the animation alongside iconic tracks “Linus and Lucy” and “Christmas Time is Here.”

Great Pumpkin Charlie Brown
Lee Mendelson Productions

Another close contender for my favorite is The Polar Express (2004). I’m a firm believer that this movie is the most magical and uplifting to watch as a child, but I’m also still a child at heart, so it’s okay! Some kiddies take the titular express train to the North Pole and meet Santa and his elves. And somehow, that’s the least interesting part.

What can I say, there’s just a quality to this movie that can never be replicated. The slightly uncanny animation never once bothered me; it’s just a different style. This movie is a little mysterious, a little rough around the edges — is that the ghost of Christmas past? What is our main character’s name? We don’t need to know. It manages to be so different, yet so adventurous, and so introspective.

Don’t listen to the people saying this movie is weird and uncanny. You’ve probably already seen it, but if you haven’t, watch and find out for yourself.

Finally, we have another black-and-white movie. How do you go about proving that Santa Claus really exists? That’s what we find out in Miracle on 34th Street (1947). You can watch the new one from 1994 as well, and that one has the talented once-child actress from Matilda too. But I IMPLORE you not to!

I understand the hesitations many people have about black-and-white movies: why watch them if today we have more color and more dimension? They’re old, so they must be slow-paced and boring. I don’t understand what they’re saying, and it’s not relevant to my life at present day.

All I can say is to give them a chance. These films made in the black-and-white era had artistic choices too! There are some gorgeous shots with beautiful setup, sets, and lighting, and it is designed to look good with dimension in grayscale. The best example I can think of from this list is the scene where George first comes home to his wife in It’s a Wonderful Life. The fire crackling and dancing, the roast spinning, and the moonlit table are etched into my mind. It’s prettier lighting than a lot of Hollywood today. 

Also, you can understand the movie. If you give it a chance beyond the first 30 minutes, that’s when you really get to see if a movie is interesting, and it’s no different with old movies. I felt this way when my parents made me watch The English Patient, which at first I thought was cruel and unusual torture compared to the Roblox slop game waiting for me upstairs (I’m 19, by the way), but then I was completely absorbed. These films are loved for a reason.

Tangent aside, Miracle on 34th Street is about a precocious girl and her single mother who are both firm non-believers in Santa Claus. That is, until they meet him, dressed as himself, in the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. He gets into some trouble, and in the end, the movie is not just about believing in Santa Claus, but about helping him, now as their friend, when he is in need.

In the end, it’s your list too. Watch whatever you’d like, and as long as you kick back with something sweet and something warm this Christmas, you’ll be doing it right.

Honorable Non-Christmas Christmas movie musts from my household:

Harry Potter. All 8 movies. They all have a Christmas scene.

The Lord of the Rings. All 3. There’s no Christmas. 

Not The Hobbit. Who is watching that?

Casablanca.

Harry Potter again.

And any cozy movie with a white winter!

Vera is a sophomore at the University of Pittsburgh in Bioengineering, and likes to write about pop culture, health, science, and entertainment.

She aspires to be a voice of both emotion and reason, and apply those same motivations to being a future physician. For now, she likes to write articles to unload feelings about topics she feels passionately about.

In her other time, she looks sadly at pictures of her dog Callie (at home, still alive), eats only authentic Chinese food in Squirrel Hill, and plays too much Pokémon GO.