In search of smudge-proof eyeliner? Volumizing mascara? A new go-to eyeshadow palette? Look no further than these top 10 eye makeup picks. In narrowing down their favorites, the Her Campus College Beauty Awards testers took into account many factors like pigmentation, staying power, wearability, and of course, aesthetics.
We get it — college consists of late nights, long, sweaty walks across campus, and probably a few tears at one point or another. There’s already enough to think about during the semester, and you shouldn’t have to worry that your mascara is running into your concealer. The CBA testers praise the following products because they’re super reliable. These mascaras will actually give you length that lasts, and these liners will actually leave precise, smudge-free results.
Apart from their strong staying power, each product listed — from liquid eyeshadow to classic lash curlers — can be used to achieve any look you’re going for. Use the matte, neutral tones of the Charlotte Tillbury Luxury Pillow Talk Palette for your trips to the dining hall, or layer its shimmering shades for your next sorority function. Add these top 10 eye makeup products of 2022 to your cosmetics bag and you’ll have no problem creating a look that’ll really make your eyes pop this semester.
Vasanti Cosmetics Kajal Waterline
This eyeliner pencil has become a staple in the CBA testers’ makeup routines. Emily and Oasiah praise the product’s ability to last all day without smudging, even on the waterline. $19.
ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara
This 99% naturally-derived mascara is worth adding to your collection. Testers Dorilyn and Maeve love its ability to lengthen, volumize, and hold a curl without flaking or smudging. $28.
Physicians Formula Mineral Wear Diamond Melt-allic Liquid Eyeshadow
This metallic liquid eyeshadow is a budget friendly pick with a bold impact. Zoë, Eboni, and Dorilyn especially love its color range and smooth formula. $10.
Tweezerman Classic Lash Curler
A high-quality eyelash curler is crucial to any makeup routine. The weight of this tool and the several replacement pads it comes with are game changers for Zoë, Kyra, and Eboni. $10.
Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
This cult favorite mascara adds length and volume to lashes without feeling clumpy. Its large brush will transform short, straight lashes, Dorilyn says. $28.
Charlotte Tillbury Luxury Palette Pillow Talk
This four-shade palette has both matte, neutral tones and shimmery colors to achieve any look you’re going for. Its convenient travel size is perfect for glamming on the go. $40.
e.l.f. Big Mood Mascara
The e.l.f. Big Mood Mascara gives lashes a huge lift at a budget-friendly cost. Zoë thinks the low price point for such high quality is unbeatable! $7.
Sephora Collection Fine Line Waterproof Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner
This waterproof, felt-tip liner is a fan favorite among testers Dorilyn, Eboni, and Maeve. The fine tip allows for precise, even application that will last from day to night. $14.
Burt’s Bees Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow
Looking for some quick glam? Olivia uses her fingers to apply this cream shadow for the perfect, subtle hint of color on her lids. This product’s blendable and long-lasting formula will not disappoint. $10.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
CBA testers Maeve and Zoë praise this Maybelline mascara for its long thin brush, which helps them to achieve a natural, clump-free lash look. $13.