Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
UCLA | Style > Beauty

There’s Crack in the Makeup

Chidera Eche Student Contributor, University of California - Los Angeles
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at UCLA chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

I have a confession to make: I used to judge women who wore makeup every day.

Not necessarily in a malicious way, but I genuinely couldn’t understand it. Why would someone willingly wake up an hour earlier to put products on their face, only to wash them all off 12 hours later? Why did people need seven different blushes? How different could two brown lip liners possibly be? I was confused. Perhaps even a little self-righteous.

And now, I owe the makeup girlies an apology. Because I’m convinced there’s crack in makeup.

I didn’t grow up wearing makeup, and looking back, I’m actually quite grateful for that. I got to experience my awkward teenage years without feeling the need to alter my appearance every morning. My face was changing, my features were developing, and I was still figuring out what I looked like. I’m glad I had the opportunity to grow into my face without feeling like I needed to correct it. That’s not to say that girls who wore makeup growing up were necessarily insecure. But for me, not wearing it meant I never developed the expectation that my face needed something extra before I could leave the house.

As I’ve gotten older, though, I’ve discovered something rather unfortunate. Makeup is really, really fun. And really, really expensive.

I used to think women who wore makeup every day were doing so because they didn’t feel beautiful without it. And while I still believe that insecurity can play a role in some women’s relationships with makeup, I’ve realized how reductive that assumption was. What if someone just likes doing their makeup? I’ve realized that I don’t necessarily wear makeup because I want to look prettier. Sometimes, I just want to see what I would look like with a little bright berry blush. A particular technique makes my eyes look bolder. A different bronzer placement changes the way my entire face looks. Certain combinations of products make me look older, while others give me a softer appearance.

It’s fascinating. It’s like discovering that your face is a canvas, and you have absolutely no obligation to paint the same thing on it every day.

Of course, as a fashion girl, I appreciated the work of artists like Pat McGrath, who make a face look like a Renaissance painting, but I did not truly understand just how much work that takes until now. There is genuine skill involved in understanding color, placement, texture, and technique. Watching someone completely transform the effect of their features with a few brushes is impressive. I understand the appeal now.

Unfortunately, understanding the appeal has also made me considerably more susceptible to the beauty aisle. I think conversations about makeup and feminism tend to become unnecessarily polarized. On one hand, there’s the argument that makeup is empowering because women should be free to express themselves however they choose. On the other, there’s the argument that makeup reinforces unrealistic beauty standards and encourages women to view their natural faces as inadequate.

I think both perspectives have something worth considering. It would be dishonest to pretend the beauty industry doesn’t profit from women’s insecurities. We’re constantly presented with new products promising to conceal, enhance, smooth, lift, brighten, or otherwise improve something about our appearance. Sometimes those messages can encourage us to see perfectly ordinary features as problems requiring expensive solutions.

But I also think it’s unfair to assume that every woman who wears makeup must secretly dislike the way she looks. Women aren’t a monolith. Our relationships with beauty are shaped by different experiences, expectations, preferences, and insecurities. For some women, makeup is a way to feel more confident in a society that places enormous value on female appearance. For others, it’s a creative outlet, a hobby, or simply an enjoyable part of their daily routine. And for many, those motivations probably overlap.

I don’t think acknowledging that makeup can be connected to insecurity is inherently insulting. Sometimes it is. That’s a legitimate conversation to have. But I also don’t think the existence of that relationship means we can confidently diagnose every woman who enjoys a full beat as insecure. At the same time, there is space for nuance. If someone offers a critique of the beauty industry or the pressure women face to look a certain way, I don’t think the immediate response needs to be defensive. If you know that you’re comfortable with your natural appearance and simply enjoy makeup, then that critique doesn’t necessarily describe your experience.

We should be able to acknowledge the industry’s problems without interpreting every criticism as a personal attack. And we should be able to enjoy makeup without pretending that every purchase is an act of feminist resistance. Sometimes it’s just a blush.

Now, let’s discuss the part of makeup that I find significantly less empowering — the price.

Because why is everything so expensive? Before I started wearing makeup, I never understood how someone could spend two hours inside an Ulta. Surely, you walk in, find the product you need, pay for it, and leave.

A straightforward transaction. Clearly not.

I recently went into Ulta looking for one very specific product: the Ole Henriksen Pout Preserve Peptide Lip Treatment. (Please, go get it. I fear I’m becoming an unpaid brand ambassador.)

Somehow, what should have been a quick shopping trip turned into an extended exploration of products I hadn’t even known existed before entering the store.

Suddenly, I was examining blushes, comparing lip products, and considering whether I needed something that, 15 minutes earlier, had never crossed my mind. I realized the beauty industry has figured something out. It’s selling us possibilities, not just products.

A new foundation promises a different finish. A new eyeshadow palette offers combinations you’ve never tried. A new lip product might be the missing piece in a look you haven’t even created yet. And once you start treating makeup as a hobby rather than a necessity, the possibilities feel endless. Which is wonderful for creativity. Less wonderful for my bank account.

I think there’s room to enjoy the fun while still questioning the beauty standards and marketing tactics surrounding it. So, to the women I once silently judged for owning an unreasonable number of lip products, I understand you now. I see the vision. I respect the artistry. And I would like to formally apologize. Just don’t ask me how much I’ve spent at Sephora. That’s between me, my bank account, and God.

Chidera is a senior working towards her Bachelors of Science in Anthropology. Her interests span fashion, culture, and women’s sexual and reproductive health. Outside of writing, she enjoys reading, knitting, and exploring creative projects that bring together style and storytelling.