The Dark Knight vs. The Batman

Although there have been many portrayals of Batman throughout the years, each one brings a unique and interesting take on the character. Recently released, “The Batman” film, directed by Matt Reeves, gave us a more in-depth look into this DC character as he navigates his role of vigilante in the unforgiving city of Gotham. 

Although the world of Batman is usually cinematically explored as dark and twisted, there are many differences between Reeves’ Batman, played by Robert Pattinson, and those that came before it. Including “The Dark Knight” trilogy directed by Christopher Nolan. 

There are many aspects of each film that distinguish them as remarkable DC films, but there are also key differences that might make the argument for one being better than the other. Let’s take “The Dark Knight” for example,  where Batman is portrayed by a younger Christian Bale who is barely starting his journey as the vigilante and making waves across the crime scene in Gotham city. 

In this portrayal of Batman, Bale presents fans with a more approachable version of the character in comparison to Pattinson. Nolan’s approach to this version of the character is more playboy millionaire by day, vigilante by night, resembling the CW’s portrayal of the DC vigilante Arrow. Meanwhile, Pattinson’s portrayal of the character appears to be more shy and awkward making him more intimidating when he wears the suit. 

Although, “The Dark Knight” explores the origins of Bruce Wayne throughout the films, giving fans a deeper understanding of the character’s motives. What makes “The Batman” so outstanding is its subtle representation of mental health through Bruce’s implied struggle with depression after the loss of his parents without explicitly giving him an origin story in the film. 

Another aspect of “The Batman” film that is depicted differently from “The Dark Knight” is Gotham itself. In Nolan’s Batman trilogy, Gotham is a crime-infested city in need of saving, but it is not as doom and gloom as Reeves’ Batman. In the new movie, Gotham is seen to be more hopeless and cynical than ever before, both visually and ideologically. 

As far as villains go, both portrayals of the Batman universe have strong villain leads that take the audience on a mental and emotional rollercoaster. While Heath Ledger’s portrayal of the Joker will forever go down in history as one of the greatest villain performances of all time, and the greatest Joker of all time, Paul Dano gives an exciting and memorable performance as The Riddler in the new Batman setting a strong foundation for more films to come. 

Ultimately, both depictions of the characters and the universes they are set in are very strong and capturing to DC fans, but Reeves’ “The Batman” film was a more engaging cinematic experience that gave fans everything they needed in a way that is more authentic to the character and Batman universe, making it the more standout film.

• the batman