I have spent half my life reading Cassandra Clare’s books. That is not the exaggeration I wish it was. I sat down and stubbornly plowed through City of Bones when I was eleven years old and here I am, a newly twenty-two, waiting (im)patiently for the first book in The Wicked Powers trilogy to be released. The Wicked Powers is the final series in The Shadowhunter Chronicles, a trilogy that readers have been promised since 2018. Almost ten years later and I’m starting to feel like I’m the character haunting the narrative.
This article mostly serves as a way to parse through why I am still so invested in this series. By all accounts, I should have grown out of Cassandra Clare’s books about half-angel/half-human demon fighters. Upon entering college, I lost a lot of the ample time it takes to read long-winded, multi-book fantasy worlds, and to be quite frank, I sometimes feel my age catching up to me when I open a young adult (YA) novel.
Despite this, The Shadowhunter Chronicles continues to have an unrelenting grip on me.
At first, I attributed this grip to sheer determination. I’ve spent eleven years reading these books, and somewhere along the way, I stopped being the target audience. Still, that’s a lot of hours, and I refuse to quit when the finish line is only three unreleased books in front of me. This doesn’t, however, explain why I still get so much enjoyment out of these stories, and recently I began to wonder, how good are the Shadowhunter novels really?
What I say about the first three books in The Mortal Instruments series (the original Shadowhunters trilogy) should be taken with a grain of salt, as I last read them in 2016. I remember finding the main characters unlikeable, and the plot definitely suffered from the Harry Potter effect. (Clary is the Chosen One who has a connection to the bigoted villain planning a mass genocide.) Also, the plot device deployed via the Jace and Clary romance (if you know you know) is simply not something I would ever like to reread.
The second series…this is where things start to get interesting. The Infernal Devices series travels back in time, following the ancestors of all the Shadowhunters we met in the first series. It’s very Victorian and very angsty, but despite its unrestrained use of tropes that were popular back in the early 2010s, I couldn’t help but get way too invested in these characters. In fact, I still find myself thinking about Will Herondale at least once every couple months. I don’t even really remember the plot of this series, I just remember loving these characters and their friendships/relationships with each other. This, I believe, is where we start to arrive at an answer to my original question: why am I still so invested in these books?
The third series is a continuation of The Mortal Instruments, following the original characters only a month after the events of the first series. This time around, the characters are far more likeable and not as prone to stupid decision-making (albeit, there is still a lot of stupid decision-making), but what makes this series so fun to read is the way that it blends with the events in The Infernal Devices, creating a clear link between the past and the present. These Shadowhunting families start to become both more familiar and more complex; they take on identities of their own and as a result, the characters become more real.
The fourth series, The Dark Artifices, follows an entirely new family, years after the events in the third series take place. The main characters of this series are—notably—seen in the third series, and this easter egg gives context to their story. There’s more nuance to their actions because, through the prior novels, we have insight into the sort of fantastical and traumatic events that impacted these characters. These characters become more fleshed-out, and although there are still distinct YA clichés, Cassandra Clare effectively uses history and lore to make the reader feel as if they are witnessing a story that extends beyond what has been written.
The last series that has been released, The Last Hours, takes readers back in time again. We are united with beloved characters from The Infernal Devices, yet this time around, we follow their children’s adventures. This series was first released during my drift away from YA, and although I eventually got around to reading and enjoying it, I couldn’t help but note that Cassandra Clare seemed to pick up on the same thing I did. The most effective way she captivates an audience is through her characters. These novels have a much larger cast of main characters because of this, and the intricacies of their relationships seem to take precedence over demon fighting far more than in previous books.
All of this to say, if you have the time and desire to invest in a 18+ book series, this is definitely an option. I can’t necessarily say that it’s good, but I can definitely vouch for its entertainment value.
I also believe that my fixation with The Shadowhunter Chronicles cannot be so easily brushed off as Stockholm Syndrome. There is certainly something to the way in which Cassandra Clare has created this world, the way in which she created these characters. She made me invest something more than my time into them; she made me invest enough emotion to withstand the dynamism of my interests. At the end of the day, I’m still here because I can’t help but wonder what will happen to the characters I’ve spent half my life knowing.