Finding Resistance While Preserving One’s Humanity
Spoiler Warning!
On November 20th, the film Sunrise on the Reaping will be released in the theaters. The film is based on the novel written by the phenomenal author, Suzanne Collins, and follows the novel The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes and acts as a prequel to the original trilogy of The Hunger Games.
https://www.hercampus.com/school/rutgers/a-review-of-sunrise-on-the-reaping-contains-spoilers/
Haymitch Abernathy And How No Ever Wins The Games
In the original trilogy of The Hunger Games, Haymitch acts as a sarcastic and cynical mentor to Katiniss Everdeen and Peeta Mellark in preparing them for the 74th and the Third Quarter Quell of the games. However, prior to being their mentor, Haymitch was the only known surviving victor of District Twelve and victor of the Second Quarter Quell with double the amount of tributes.They are made to reinforce control and prevent rebellion, but most importantly, as revealed in Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, it is a reflection of the nature of humanity.
Haymitch Abernathy, was born on the day of the reaping, which marks how the games are an inescapable yearly routine, with another sunrise symbolizing another reaping. He originally did not get reaped into the games despite it being portrayed that he did by the media. After Lenore Dove Baird attempts to help the fallen tribute,Woodbine, after he attempts to escape, Haymitch, in his attempt to protect Lenore Dove, is selected to replace Woodbine as tribute for the Second Quarter Quell.
With his mentors being the prior victor’s, Mags and Wiress, Beetee’s mentorship most directly aids Haymitch’s victory in the games. Originally intended for Haymitch and his son, Ampert, who was reaped after Beetee’s attempt to rebel, Beetee directs Haymitch and Ampert to target the arena’s subterranean water channel, and search around the seams of the force field for a structural flaw to exploit.
Once in the games, the arena is a vibrant and scenic oasis that hides the toxicity contained within the meadow, forest, and mountain of the arena. Ultimately, the plan fails and Ampert is killed by the mutts leading Haymitch to team up with Maysille Donner, a fellow tribute from district twelve who saves him after an attack from career tributes. They both form an alliance but are forced to go their separate ways once only a few tributes are left. At the end, with only Haymitch and Silka Sharp, a tribute from district one, left, Haymitch utilizes the force field, after earlier discovering that anything thrown into it bounces back, to have her axe throw itself back hitting her instead and marks Haymitch’s victory as the last tribute standing.
Despite Haymitch’s victory, it was interpreted by President Snow to be an act of rebellion by outsmarting the Capitol, using what was originally meant to keep the tributes contained in the arena as a weapon. An act that is punished by him losing all his loved ones in district twelve and marking his descent into alcoholism. Despite the promise of glory granted to the label of a victor, the victors are forced to return to relive the trauma of the games by mentoring the next groups of tributes and are threatened with retaliation if they do not conform to the Capitol.
Although Haymitch was not able to create lasting change through his year of the games, he was able to mentor two victors that did. He later on became a leading figure in the rebellion, and ultimately kept his promise to Lenoard Dove to not let the sun rise on another reaping day.
Finding Humanity Within the Games
The Politics of Panem, and The Hunger Games, creates a dehumanization of how we value life as it turns the deaths of tributes into a spectacle by televising the reaping, interviewing the tributes to create a public image, and televising the deaths of the tributes as something for the Capitol citizens to bet on. However, the tributes chose to preserve their sense of humanity, rather than bending to who the capital wants to be, which sparks the flames of hope within the districts that catch fire, starting the rebellion against the Capitol of Panem.
We particularly see this through the victors of district twelve Lucy Gray Baird, Haymitch Abernathy, Peeta Mellark, and Katniss Everdeen. Lucy Gray Baird’s quote, “I think there is a natural goodness born into us all. You can either cross that line into evil, or not. And it’s our life’s work to stay on the right side of that line” counters the worldview of President Snow.
President Snow, at the end of the novel Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, believes that the Hunger Games reflects the idea that the world is an arena. Snow opposes the idea that there is an inherent goodness to people and that a spectacle is necessary to display what happens when order is dismantled.
That is challenged primarily by Katniss, but also Haymitch, in that they both got reaped into the games attempting to protect someone they loved, and attempted to protect their fellow tributes while in the games that challenges the idea that individuals are inherently self-preserving. The act that sparked the hopes of a rebellion was the ending of the 74th games with Peeta stating “One of us has to die. They have to have their victor”, and Katniss replying “No. They don’t. Why should they?” in which she chose to consume the nightlock berries that reject the idea from the President that individuals are inherently self-preserving. By choosing death on their own terms, it forced the Capitol to declare them both as victors.
After the games, President Snow visits Katniss and confronts her about the act of defiance she made, and how the entire system could collapse. That the fragility of the system collapsing would result in the districts tearing each other apart, and that the games presenting a victor contain hope. We see that reflected through his discussion with the Gamemaker, Seneca Crane, as he states “Hope. It is the only thing stronger than fear. A little hope is effective. A lot of hope is dangerous. A spark is fine, as long as it’s contained.’”
The unity of the tributes sparks the embers of hope that drives the uprising of the rebellion. Through the manufactured division between the districts, but also the districts to those in the Capitol, the Hunger Games provides a mirror to the world we live in. Despite being a dystopian series, the games act as a warning against tyranny, the importance of empathy, and questions whether we are like the citizens of the Capitol: desensitized to issues for the sake of amusement.