Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
UPR | Culture > Entertainment

Forget ‘Coraline 2’: Spink And Forcible Deserve A Queer Prequel

Fabiola Canales Student Contributor, University of Puerto Rico - Rio Piedras
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at UPR chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

April Spink and Miriam Forcible had been young once. They stood beneath stage lights, wore extravagant costumes, and heard audiences applaud their names. Somewhere in between dressing rooms and final curtains, they had also fallen in love. By the time Coraline arrives at the Pink Palace, all that remains of those years are faded photographs, old theater posters, and two women who have grown so accustomed to sharing a life that neither can finish a sentence without the other interrupting to argue. 

Fans have spent over 15 years asking what happened to Coraline next, but I’ve never seen anyone ask what happened to Spink and Forcible that led them to the Pink Palace. 

I understand the obsession with wanting a Coraline sequel, because this story has followed me for practically my entire life. Coraline is the first movie I remember watching — and at the ripe age of two, my introduction to horror. When it premiered in 2009, my mother’s best friend was stationed at Guantánamo Bay in Cuba, where he watched it at a drive-in theater. As he quoted in a letter he sent, he couldn’t stop thinking about how he envisioned me being like Coraline when I grew older. Once the film was released on DVD, he mailed me a now-rare two-sided edition containing both the 2D and 3D versions, complete with those old pink-and-green cardboard glasses. Since then, I have read the book seven times, watched the movie more times than I can count, and even got a Coraline tattoo on the back of my arm. 

I would happily return to the Pink Palace, just to hear that haunting soundtrack and crawl through the little door one more time. I just don’t think Coraline needs to be placed in danger again for us to return. 

Instead of moving forward with the story, I want the story to go backwards — and perhaps, downstairs. Miss Spink and Miss Forcible have an entire life hidden below Coraline’s apartment: two retired actresses, dozens of moments in the theater, way too many Scottish terriers, and a queer love story the movie never mentioned out loud. What if the next Coraline story isn’t really a sequel? What if it finally showed us how April and Miriam found the theater, the Pink Palace, and most importantly, each other? 

The demand for another film is certainly still alive. Its theatrical re-release in 2024 earned more than $50M globally, proving that audiences are still willing to crawl through that eerie tunnel more than 15 years after the movie premiered. However, in my opinion, Coraline already received the ending she deserved. She rescued her parents, freed the ghost children, and defeated the Other Mother. She returned home appreciating her imperfect real life and breaking that vicious, child-abducting cycle without losing the curiosity that made her an explorer. Another mysterious door and another button-eyed villain could easily feel like a repetition of a story that already ended where it needed to. 

The Two Versions of April and Miriam

Acknowledging the fact that I got this idea after rewatching Welcome to Derry for the third time, I imagine the prequel following the version of Spink and Forcible created for the 2009 movie — mainly because stop-motion animation gives us so much visual material to work with. The colors, costumes, photographs, posters, and their comedic Other World performance already suggest what their younger versions might have looked like. Still, I would want the story to borrow the stranger and darker details from the novel. The movie would provide the prequel’s appearance, while the book could provide its “bones.”

In Neil Gaiman’s 2002 novel, Miss Spink and Miss Forcible are retired actresses living in the flat beneath Coraline’s family. Their home was crowded with old photographs, memories from the theater, and their aging Scottish terriers. They talk about their former careers as if time never passed, even though Gaiman’s descriptions show that it’s been decades since the crowd last applauded them. They are funny and gently dramatic in the novel, but they’re also the first adults to recognize that Coraline is in danger. After reading her tea leaves, they give Coraline a stone with a hole in its center, which eventually helps her locate the souls stolen by the Other Mother. 

The novel makes them seem like they have some sort of mystical quality. They may not completely understand what lives beyond the little door, but they sense that something is wrong before Coraline even crawls through. Their Other World counterparts appear young again and perform endlessly for an audience of dogs. When Coraline returned during her challenge, that beautiful illusion had rotted. The two actresses have become a grotesque, conjoined creature trapped inside a cocoon-like sac, guarding one of the ghost children’s souls. 

The movie takes the same basic characters and makes them brighter, louder, and much more theatrical — I assume this is to make the movie more market-friendly. Their flat resembles an old dressing room that nobody bothered to clean. It’s overflowing with costumes, taffy dishes, and yearning for what they used to be. Their personalities also become easier to separate. Spink is intuitive and gloriously dramatic, while Forcible is blunter and more skeptical. When Spink sees a strange hand in Coraline’s tea leaves, Forcible turns the cup and insists that it looks like a giraffe. They disagree on almost everything, but they do it with the essence of two people who’ve had the same dynamic for years already. 

Their Other World performance is one of the biggest additions, in my opinion. Spink appears as a mermaid and siren, while Forcible rises from a shell like Botticelli’s Venus. Then, as if being practically naked onstage weren’t dramatic enough, they unzip their older bodies like costumes (described as “shells” in Gaiman’s novel) and emerge as young and fresh trapeze artists. It’s glamorous, ridiculous and disturbing — which makes them unforgettable.

The Other Mother (also known as the Beldam in the novel) probably didn’t recreate their pasts accurately, in my opinion. As explained, she takes people’s memories and desires and stretches them into something irresistible. As seen on the previously-attached poster (seen when Coraline first enters Spink and Forcible’s flat in the movie), I like to theorize that the Other Mother copied these details to reveal how much they missed feeling young, beautiful, and admired. Either way, the scene gives us a glimpse of the women hidden beneath the dressing gowns and rheumatic legs. 

Their final transformation also reveals an interesting difference. The novel traps them together inside a sac (almost like some sort of womb), while the movie twists their younger bodies into a sticky, wax-like taffy monster. In both versions, their Other World copies are forced together until neither can exist independently. 

a prequel i don’t need button eyes to see

To keep the time and storyline accurate to the movie (which was set in 2009), I would set their prequel between the late 1960s and early 1970s, while April and Miriam are still young actresses moving between British theatres and touring productions. I think this era would fit the sort of aesthetic that’s visible in the movie, such as the seaside costumes and the painted sets. 

The story could begin during the summer of 1968, backstage at a small seaside theater. April is trying to repair a sparkling mermaid costume minutes before a performance and making the situation sound like the end of her career. Miriam is reminding her that she warned her not to pull the fabric so tightly, even as she’s already kneeling beside her with a needle and a thread. Before they became lovers, they were rivals who wanted the same roles and couldn’t stop criticising each other’s performances. April thinks Miriam takes herself too seriously, whilst Miriam thinks April treats every inconvenience like the final act of a Greek tragedy.

Their relationship could develop quietly in the spaces surrounding the stage. I envision them sharing mirrors in cramped dressing rooms, falling asleep on each other’s shoulders on long train rides, and rehearsing their lines after everyone else has gone home. I think it would be beautiful to highlight how fearless they truly are onstage. Spink can dress like a siren and sing, and Forcible rises from a shell without a bit of embarrassment. What looks like a slow-burn enemies-to-friendship, becomes something else. For example, brushing hands beneath restaurant tables and finding excuses to share hotel rooms while touring. 

Eventually, their company could travel to the United States, bringing them through small theaters across the Pacific Northwest. This is where the book’s supernatural elements could begin entering the story. Maybe April, because of where she comes from, was taught how to read tea leaves, but she starts experiencing things in the U. S. that she cannot explain. Both the movie and the book have the following quote from Miss Spink: “Never wear green in your dressing room.” This comes from an old theatrical superstition that said green stage lighting or green costumes were thought to bring bad luck or make actors blend poorly in older theater sets, according to CZs World. What if Miss Spink tells an actor to move during a rehearsal and then a green stagelight falls onstage? I’d center the storyline on supernatural events happening in a theater rumored to be haunted years before they got there. As a punchline, Miriam initially dismissed April’s instincts, just as she later dismisses the hand on Coraline’s tea leaves as a giraffe. 

Maybe that’s where April finds the “seeing stone,” perhaps a predecessor to the stone she makes and gives to Coraline in the film. Since April is capable of divination — the practice of predicting the future — she was capable of accurately reading Coraline’s tea leaves and giving her wise advice out of a similar experience. 

As the 1970s continue, their careers begin to change. New performers arrive, their usual theaters close due to the “Television Boom” from the late 1950s, and roles for women their age slowly become harder to find.  Eventually, they arrive in Oregon and find the Pink Palace. 

I would end the prequel years later, with April sitting near the window as a moving truck arrives outside. She watches a small girl with blue hair step into the garden and immediately begin exploring. Miriam calls from the other room and asks what she is staring at. 

“New neighbors,” April says. 

More than a coming-out story

April and Miriam’s relationship was eventually confirmed to be romantic by the novel’s author Neil Gaiman through a Tumblr post on October 24th, 2016. However, the movie never identifies them as a couple. According to the Coraline Wiki, “It should be noted that the original book (set in England) came out in 2002, but same-sex marriage was not made legal in England until March 29, 2014, meaning that during the time period the original story takes place in, Miss Forcible and Miss Spink could not have gotten married even if they wanted to. The same is true for the movie version, which instead takes place in Ashland, Oregon, as the state of Oregon didn’t legalize gay marriage until May 19, 2014 but the movie came out in 2009.” Many viewers assume that they’re sisters, friends or roommates, even though they have different last names and share what appears to be an entire lifetime. 

I will always understand the desire and hype for Coraline 2. I have learnt that loving a fictional world means wanting to stay inside it for as long as possible. But continuing that world doesn’t require placing Coraline in danger again. The novel gives April and Miriam mystery, intuition, and darkness. The movie gives them color, camp, and a glittering glimpse of the performers they may have once been. Together, those versions already contain the outline of a strange, romantic, and deeply queer prequel. 

I don’t think that we need to find out what happened to Coraline after closing the little door. I think that, perhaps, we need to discover what happened before she ever opened it. I believe that maybe the story worth telling has been living downstairs all along. 

Fabiola Canales is a junior writer for Her Campus UPR, where she writes about pop culture, fashion, music, feminism, and all the beautiful — and sometimes confusing — parts of girlhood. Through her articles, she hopes to represent young women finding their place in the world while growing into adulthood. As a longtime Her Campus reader, Fabiola joined the chapter to become part of a creative sisterhood where women can feel seen, understood, and a little less lonely.

Fabiola is a second-year Communication student, majoring in Journalism and Information at the University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras campus. She speaks English, Spanish, and French. She began writing poetry at the age of seven, later writing and publishing two romance books. This earned her the pen name of “Ladybell”, which she often uses. Before journalism, she worked as a child actress through many projects in film, radio, advertisements, and television, including three years as the head judge in Telemundo’s “Puerto Rico Gana”. She also created the “K-pop Corner”, a YouTube channel featuring weekly K-pop news. In the future, she hopes to pursue journalism without ever losing the freedom, personality, or heart behind her voice.

At heart, Fabiola is a quirky romantic who collects dolls as though each one carries a tiny piece of the world. Her creative superpower is turning the struggles of everyday life into romantic prose, transforming the toughest feelings into a tender and comforting story. Fabiola is happiest surrounded by stories, nostalgia, shades of pink, and the belief that true beauty lies in freedom.