Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
BU | Culture > Entertainment

‘Yesteryear’: Is It Really Worth The Hype? 

Orly Charrabe Student Contributor, Boston University
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at BU chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

I can’t remember a debut novel that’s gotten as much hype as the early 2026 release of Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke.

This book felt like one that everyone and their mother had some sort of association with. Whether you’re an avid reader or only retain the loudest recommendations that permeate the outskirts of BookTok, this book has made itself known.  

In 2024, Burke, a first-time author, sold Yesteryear to Knopf in a book deal with Amazon MGM, which quickly retained the film rights, with Anne Hathaway already attached to the project and set to be the main star. The book came out in April 2026 and has already sold over a million copies, spending 17 consecutive weeks on the New York Times Bestseller list.

As a piously devoted member of BookTok and the bookish pockets of Instagram, I kept putting off reading this book. It was haunting me. Every monthly reading recap, bookstore highlight, book lover’s recommendation, and bedside table placement holder made space for this book. However you define yourself on the spectrum of “reader,” it seemed to me that everyone had already read it by Oct. 2026, when I finally picked it up.

As much as I feel like an echo of every other BookTok voice, within the first pages, I was hooked.

This satirical psychological thriller is a social commentary about a “tradwife” who wakes up in a 19th-century version of the life she has specifically manufactured. 

The story follows Natalie Heller Mills, a social media influencer who’s carefully curated every aspect of her life to perform as a picturesque, conservative, and traditional Christian mother who embodies a rustic, pioneer lifestyle on a working Idaho ranch. Suddenly thrust into an 1855 version of her life, the modernity Natalie has so carefully concealed is stripped away, and with it, the agency that’s allowed her to manipulate the very patriarchal structures she so enthusiastically promotes. No longer able to curate the conditions of her domesticity, Natalie is forced to experience what it means to be subjected to the ideals she’s built her online identity around.

The novel punches the gut of the pronatalist movement, delicately clashing against the social media idealism of a traditional lifestyle with the often oppressive realities of modern and historical patriarchy. Burke tells a story that seems quite familiar, but the sheerly honest and raw perspective of the protagonist, Natalie, provides an eerie twist. It’s incredible how such an unreliable narrator can preach with such honesty and transparency. 

Natalie, though appearing submissive and passive online, is an absolute firecracker. She has carefully contorted every aspect of her life, even sculpting her dud-of-a-husband almost like a piece of pottery; he functions basically as an appliance, created in her image. By contrast, Natalie is treated like a child in the 1855 version of her home, where the backhanded autonomy she once wielded over her household is replaced by an expectation of unquestioning obedience. 

This book feels accessible and the different internal questions create pockets of engagement for different types of readers. In the simplest way, this book is pure entertainment. I found myself speeding through pages, itching to know where the story was going. However, the book simultaneously poses larger societal questions within each of its pages, toggling between battles of modern internet rage-engagement and the attention economy, as well as a broader allegory of the modern woman and what it takes to perform an idealized life.

Yesteryear’s popularity is a testament not only to how entertaining and thought-provoking the novel is, but also to how incredibly divisive it is. The book taps directly into cultural anxieties about social media and gender roles. Readers are split regarding the novel’s satirical nature, supporters highlighting the sharp critique of commercialized domesticity in toxic social media portrayals, while critics argue that the book serves more as a shallow political message rather than nuanced fiction.

Personally, I think the beauty of this book is that no matter which path you take, it forces some type of reflection on the reader. I loved the book because of how much I hated it. 

Natalie is beyond unlikeable. Her character is cunning, controlling, deceptive, and calculated. Yet, there’s so much of her that I think readers can find in themselves. Because this novel is so character-driven, I firmly believe that what you take away from this book is largely a reflection of the way you understand Natalie, how you understand her “truths,” and what they mean for how you see the world.

Ultimately, Yesteryear is as uncomfortable as it is entertaining, and that’s precisely what makes it worth reading.

Whether you love or hate Natalie, or just find a little too much of yourself in her, Burke leaves you questioning just how much of life’s construction is truly our own, and the agency we bring to the table. 

Want to keep up with HCBU? Make sure to like us on Facebook, follow us on Instagram, check out our Pinterest board, watch us on TikTok, and read our latest Tweets!

Hi, my name is Orly! I am a current sophmore studying International Relations at Boston University. I love reading, walking, and side-questing in a new city. I think Rio is a perfect movie and I am usually listening to Olivia Dean! I am so excited to write more for Her Campus!