KATSEYE is undoubtedly one of the most recognizable girl groups in the current pop era. They’re everywhere, from award shows to magazines and entertainment shows. While you can’t escape them, the controversy surrounding the group seems to keep up the pace.
On Nov. 3, KATSEYE was set to perform their sold-out Little Caesars Arena show in Detroit as part of their WILDWORLD TOUR. Fans were eager to see the group perform live, especially since this tour marked a significant step for the group, from small theater venues to massive, packed-out arenas.
However, 30 minutes before the show started, the concert was abruptly postponed after Megan Skiendiel fell ill. By the time the announcement was made, fans were already inside the venue, and two of the four members, Lara Raj and Yoonchae, had already come out for soundcheck.
The announcement left the crowd visibly shocked, with some breaking down in tears. Fans were disappointed by the sudden announcement after spending money on hotels, transportation, and concert tickets to see KATSEYE, only for it to be canceled at the last minute on a projector screen.
While it’s understandable that the concert was postponed because a member was sick, the incident added to the growing conversation surrounding KATSEYE lineup changes and absences from public appearances. Although the members are not responsible for scheduling decisions, questions remain about how effectively the group’s management and public relations team have communicated these changes to fans. As a result, members often have to publicly defend themselves against public scrutiny and face backlash over circumstances out of their control.
Less than 24 hours after the concert was postponed, a rumor spread throughout the community that the members went to the club the night before the concert to celebrate Raj’s 21st birthday, and the “reason” for the cancellation was that the members, particularly Megan, were too hungover to perform.
It wasn’t until member Lara Raj addressed the rumors herself on Weverse, publicly denying the false claims and stating that the company, HYBE, and Geffen Records would “never allow the members to attend a party after canceling a show,” that the rumor finally started to settle down.
Even before Lara addressed the rumors, some fans called into question the validity of the rumors, pointing out that the footage was actually from April, after KATSEYE’s Coachella performance.
Thanks to Raj and the help of Eyekons, KATSEYE’s name was cleared of any wrongdoing in this whole fiasco, yet HYBE and Geffen Records, the actual companies responsible for managing the group, did not put out a statement to clear up the misunderstanding, leaving the members and fans to put out the fire.
Since when have fans and the members been responsible for managing and communicating for a group in times of crisis? In HYBE and Geffen Records’ case, since forever! Time and time again, HYBE and Geffen Records have shown that providing clarification to a confused audience about the status and well-being of their artists is not at the top of their priorities.
The mishandling of Manon Bannerman’s hiatus earlier this year showed a glaring problem with their communication and transparency. Fans were left confused. They were told by the agencies that Bannerman was placed on hiatus due to health-related issues. Simultaneously, Bannerman herself stated that she was healthy while making indirect comments about the circumstances of her hiatus, including that “sometimes things unfold in ways we don’t fully control.” Without a clear statement, this left her message open to thousands of different interpretations by fans, many believing that she was forced into a hiatus due to mistreatment, racism, and problems with management.
Although we do not know the real reason for Bannerman’s absence, it is clear that HYBE and Geffen Records’ lack of communication has only made things worse for the group.
Anyone who owns a brand knows how valuable and important public relations is. It is the foundation for building any meaningful relationship between consumer and seller. So often, that aspect of public relations is lost and forgotten. People focus on the more glamorous parts of PR, like booking a front-cover magazine gig, managing social media, and posting cute aesthetic pictures on the gram, but there is much more to it.
One of the reasons why so many people purchase, follow, and seek out an item or service is because the brand has built a reputation audiences deem worthy of buying from.
In the digital age of social media, watching and listening to influencers, TikTokers, and, yes, girl groups all fit under that scope. KATSEYE is no different; they are a brand too, and need to nurture a relationship with their audience to grow.
People want accountability and transparency. It doesn’t matter if it comes from a TikToker with 100k followers, a YouTuber with a million followers, or a million-dollar corporation. People expect the person they are listening to and buying from to have integrity and be upfront with what’s happening. If they are unable to be honest, the second-best course of action is to take accountability and own up to your mistakes and fault in the situation.
There will always be something out of the public relations team’s control. They’re not gods. They can’t control the weather or whether a member gets injured, so if an event or concert has to be canceled or postponed, it unfortunately has to be done. As long as the team recognizes and empathizes with the disappointment and inconvenience consumers may experience, and explains what happened, more often than not, consumers are much more understanding.
Yet the team’s refusal to clear up outright lies and misinformation, cancelling a long-awaited event at the last minute, then being vague about the reasoning and not acknowledging or apologizing for the time and money wasted is a choice, and it’s not a very good one.