We have all been there: sitting on the metro on a Friday night, scrolling through group chats and secretly hoping someone will cancel that night’s plans so we can stay in our bedrooms. For years, saying “yes” to every invitation, favor, or academic demand could feel like the price of belonging. The fear of disappointing others dictated our schedules, leaving our generation chronically overwhelmed.
Then came the cultural shift. TikTok feeds and Instagram carousels began urging us to “protect our peace” at all costs. Being less available suddenly became a lifestyle, and even a badge of honor. But somewhere along the way, something fractured. In our quest to escape the emotional exhaustion of people-pleasing, did we swing the pendulum too far toward self-absorption?
The Defense Behind the Pleaser
The instinct to constantly please everyone around us rarely stems from pure kindness. Bruna Gesser, a psychologist specializing in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Schema Therapy and working with both adolescents and adults, explains more about this pattern.
According to Gesser, people-pleasing can be understood as a protective strategy learned early in life — a pattern in which we start to associate being accepted with never causing trouble, keeping the peace, and anticipating everyone else’s needs.
“When that person begins to realize the cost of this pattern — such as exhaustion, resentment, difficulty identifying what they want, and unbalanced relationships —, a counter-movement naturally emerges,” Gesser explains.
While learning to say “no” is an act of liberation, turning self-prioritization into a rigid shield creates a whole new problem. As Gesser points out, leaving behind the belief of “I must please everyone” only to adopt “I owe nothing to anyone“ can simply be just another defense mechanism disguised as empowerment.
True balance lies in acknowledging our own needs while remaining capable of negotiating, staying flexible, and sustaining bonds with others.
The Trap of Pop Therapy And Low Social Battery
Social media has democratized mental health conversations, but it has also turned nuanced psychological concepts into viral catchphrases. In practice, therapy language can easily become a convenient vocabulary for emotional detachment, avoidance, or an unwillingness to handle everyday frustrations.
“Saying ‘I am prioritizing myself’ does not automatically make an attitude healthy,” Gesser warns. “A healthy boundary protects someone without discarding the other person. When used defensively, boundaries often just serve to avoid guilt, shame, vulnerability, or any emotional discomfort.”
Take the increasingly familiar “I have no social battery” cancellation. Social exhaustion can be a genuine physical and emotional state. But when our personal mood becomes a free pass to disregard someone else’s time and effort, self-care can easily cross the line into relational neglect.
But don’t take me wrong: taking care of yourself does not eliminate emotional accountability. If plans need to change, true care can look simple, like giving notice in advance, acknowledging the impact on the other person, and rescheduling as soon as possible.
Why We Fear Healthy Friction
Have you noticed how easy it has become to ghost, block, or label someone as “toxic” instead of having an awkward conversation? Confrontation feels intimidating because it stirs up rejection, guilt, and the chance of being misunderstood.
Many young adults were raised in households where expressing feelings was discouraged, or where arguments led straight to days of silence or emotional rupture. Consequently, avoiding dialogue feels much safer than stepping into it. Psychologically, this can be understood through the concept of experiential avoidance: dodging discomfort may bring immediate relief, but that short-term feeling steadily affects our capacity to maintain long-term intimacy.
Except in circumstances involving abuse or persistent disrespect — where walking away is essential self-protection —, relationships do not grow stronger through the absence of conflict. They deepen through repair. Cultivating real emotional maturity means staying present through disagreements, speaking up, and actively listening to how our actions impact the people we care about.
Autonomy vs. Hyper-Independence
The modern insistence that we do not need anyone else can feed an increasingly lonely way of life.
As Gesser highlights, there is a fundamental difference between healthy autonomy and rigid self-sufficiency. Autonomy allows us to make our own choices, stand up our values, and set meaningful limits. Hyper-independence, on the other hand, can turn needing support into something that feels like a shameful weakness.
But human beings are relational by nature. Real closeness requires a mutual exchange of vulnerability. If we constantly hide our needs behind a wall of total independence, we deny others the opportunity to truly know us, leaving us feeling isolated even in a crowded room.
The real goal is interdependence: learning to take care of ourselves while recognizing that needing each other is an essential part of the human experience.
Finding The Middle Ground
Breaking the people-pleasing cycle should not mean turning into an emotional island. Compromise is one of the quiet foundations of connection. Yielding in certain moments does not mean erasing your identity; it means recognizing that, in relationships we value, our preferences are not always the only ones that matter.
To navigate that line, Gesser suggests an internal reality check before turning down a conversation, an invite, or a shared effort:
“Am I saying no because this crosses a real boundary, or simply because I do not want to deal with the discomfort this situation brings? Is this choice protecting me from something genuinely harmful, or is it merely sparing me from the inevitable discomfort of relating, negotiating, and being challenged?”
Prioritizing yourself is necessary. But true maturity is not about choosing between total self-sacrifice and absolute detachment — it is about building firm boundaries with an open, considerate heart.
———————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————
The article above was edited by Isabella Scaramucci
Liked this type of content? Check Her Campus Cásper Líbero home page for more!