Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
Wisconsin | Culture > Digital

BEAN SOUP THEORY: WHEN “THIS DOESN’T APPLY TO ME” BECOMES “YOU’RE EXCLUDING ME”

Julia Walkowicz Student Contributor, University of Wisconsin - Madison
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at Wisconsin chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

How internet culture cultivates an egocentric mindset (and we need to cut it out) 

If you’ve never heard of Bean Soup Theory, you’ve still almost definitely experienced the parasocial phenomenon it refers to. 

Let’s go back a little. 

In 2023, “crunchy mom” influencer @vibinggranolamom took to TikTok to share a recipe for bean soup with her followers. “All my anemic girlies this one is for you” the caption read. The video quickly went viral, with over ten thousand viewers liking the post and responding with messages about how they were going to try the recipe themselves. 

However, what began as a normal recipe video soon devolved into chaos as viewers requested modifications for her popular recipe for bean soup – because they didn’t like beans. Or they wanted the soup to include meat. Or they were allergic to beans. Or beans made their stomach hurt. 

While @vibinggranolamom didn’t intend to garner national attention with her soup (which I think looks yum by the way) – here we are three years later. Users have taken the video as an example of Bean Soup Theory – a social media phenomenon whereby a public and visible posts draw annoyingly egocentric or self-interested responses that ignore the context of the original post and attempt to steer conversation toward the responder’s own personal feelings or situation. 

For example, a user seeing a video with a bean soup recipe and commenting “Are there options for this recipe without beans? I don’t like beans” or seeing a video in Spanish and commenting, “Why is this in Spanish? Why would you expect me to know Spanish?” 

Bean Soup Theory even has its own page on Miriam Webster’s Dictionary (We’ve come far from a post about a vegan, high iron recipe). The page lists comments from users on social media, like these below: 

Just a friendly reminder that not every single piece of content on the internet was made specifically for you & your preferences. Scrolling away is always an option. Bean soup theory is alive and well unfortunately. @itsdanielleryan, Threads, 19 June 2026

Don’t make me tap the bean soup theory sign! ✨Your opinion and experience actually doesn’t need to be shared all the time!

@daggersmctimbers, BlueSky, 23 Dec. 2025

Just like you’re never more than 6ft away from a rat, you’re never more than one click away from an ill-informed comment on Facebook. … The bean soup theory truly is a depressing reality. “We’re letting kids in for 1,” “BUT WHAT ABOUT ME I’M 78!” Matthew Evans, The Chester (England) Standard, 19 Dec. 2025. 

Even if I’m late to the trend, Bean Soup Theory should be a wake up call for everyone about the ways that we communicate, find meaning and foster community on the internet. 

We live in an era where you can share every thought you have at the press of a button, ricocheting it outwards to millions of viewers. While the internet has the power to bring people together (circa, email-pen pals, app-based dating, zoom calls with grandma) – Bean Soup Theory shows us that it also has the potential to tear us apart. 

A cellphone is a microphone that transcends all barriers, instantly sharing with the world what you, (yes you!) believe. However, it’s cultivated a space where users feel that their own identities are constantly a part of conversation and therefore relevant at all times. If ignored, this is a blow to their entire sense of self – inflated beyond belief due to an internet algorithm which wormholes them into an echo chamber of likeminded users. This behavior carried off the internet leads to people who are more self centered, less likely to hear others opinions and focused on the validation of their own unique identity. 

Don’t get me wrong. I think we’re all special. But, I do think anyone who comments on a post about a bean soup asking for an accommodation for a recipe without beans – needs to look in a mirror and touch grass. Not every post on the internet can be for everyone. We’ve lost the ability to see something we aren’t interested in and realize, maybe that post just isn’t for us. 

The internet is an incredible place where you can be you and find others who understand exactly how magical you are – but that doesn’t mean every corner of the web is catered to your needs. There doesn’t always need to be a specific accommodation just for you. 

When scrolling through the internet, keep my girl @vibingcrunchymama in mind. Just because everyone can hear your voice with the click of a button, doesn’t mean they have to. If we remember that the internet is a shared space for all people, but not every post is meant for everyone at all times – maybe we can have our beans and eat them too.

(But only if you want to, if not, just keep scrolling). 

Julia Walkowicz

Wisconsin '28

Julia Walkowicz is Co-President of HerCampus Wisconsin majoring in History and Journalism. In her free time, she loves to read, sing and be outside.