Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
UCSB | Culture > Entertainment

Love Beyond Time: A Look At “We Live In Time”

Updated Published
Claralyn Manning Student Contributor, University of California - Santa Barbara
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at UCSB chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

John Crowely‘s and A24‘s We Live In Time is a 2024 film that depicts romance, comedy, and heartbreak. The film, featuring Andrew Garfield and Florence Pugh, throws viewers into a narrative of love and grief. Although Tobias and Almut, the two main protagonists, have a sweet beginning, the story revolves around their emotional journey as they acknowledge the long-term effects of terminal illness— particularly ovarian cancer.  

(Spoiler Warning!! Be aware of possible spoilers! Come back to this article after you watched it!)

Times Unfolding Story: An Overview Of The Movie 

Through their powerful performances, Garfield and Pugh’s intimacy has lifted this film to a new level of genuineness and deeply rooted emotion, touching on hard subjects like connection, cancer, and mourning. Because it feels extremely real and sets the viewers equal with the gravity of the tragedy, their chemistry resonates with viewers. The film relies on a Hollywood technique described as “tried and tested” in which a character with a terminal disease must navigate a sad romance. Even though this story is widely recognized, “We Live In Time” feels new because of the lead actor’s nuanced and vulnerable performance.  

The Secret to a Successful Tragicomedy

Romantic comedies have traditionally relied on the push (hardships) and pull (intimacy and/or laughter) themes to captivate audiences. The film’s push and pull anchors gradually affect the two main protagonists. Almut (played by Pugh) is ferociously self-sufficient and warm, whereas Tobias (played by Garfield) is youthful, charming, and sensitive. Both establish a dynamic that draws the audience in and helps them comprehend their love story. 

The reality of what may have been an unforeseeable plot is made tragic yet memorable by Garfield and Pugh’s performance. Although Pugh’s serene determination sustains her character’s cancer journey from being disproportionately emotional; Garfield’s portrayal of a man who must accept his lover’s impending death from terminal cancer is painful. Their connection breathes life into the viewers that love, even in terms of loss, is worth all the pain. 

Cancer On The Sliver Screen 

The Hollywood film industry have been for decades perusing themes of terminal illnesses, in particular cancer. It speaks to a universal human experience that captivates anxieties, vulnerability, and how fragile life can be. This issue is very universal in real life and is connect to narratives that experience the long-term effects of illnesses. 

Some examples of films like: The Fault In Our Stars, A Walk To Remember, and Me Before You show how cinema has returned to this narrative structure time and time again. 

Hollywood’s continued interest in using terminal cancer as a plot strikes a chord of emotional arcs from the beginning of the relationship, the diagnosis, treatments and later death. Yet, this subject matter can be easily misunderstood if not approached with sensitivity, as audiences have seen these stories unfold repeatedly over the years. 

The way that cancer is portrayed as a component of the meaning of the journey versus understanding the topic of cancer and how “We Live In Time” is way different from than films prior. This film in particular does not use cancer as a laughing point, but instead explores the intersection of how sickness can control love and loss. This is demonstrated by how a relationship might have a closer bond since there is a threat of death. 

Want to learn more about the genre and narrative used in this film? Click here: https://www.imdb.com/list/ls004695995/ or https://www.cancerhealth.com/slideshow/essential-films-about-cancer

Love’s Bitter Sweet Symphony: Cancer Diagnosis 

Every other year, it seems as if there is another film coming out of the cinema about a narrative depiction of a young couple whose love story is cut short by terminal illness. These depictions succeed in the box office, not because of who is starring in the film, but rather how the universal emotions of fear of death, hope for the future, and the pain of watching someone you love pass while enduring immense pain. This can seem repetitive, since Hollywood continues to create narratives that reflect hard-core life situations. On the other hand, the recurrent success illustrates how these common themes and narratives can breathe new life into new meanings. 

We Live In Time capitalizes on the lengthy cinematic heritage of romances that are ultimately centered around cancer, and enhanced with outstanding performances and a contemporary sensibility. At the same time, whilst acknowledging the overall seriousness of the themes and narratives that are being portrayed, the film never downplays the value of humor and love. This film acts as a reminder that the viewer will always be moved by the grand feeling of love mixed with sorrow, regardless of how many times Hollywood repeats this narrative. 

Conclusion: The Curtains Close

John Crowley curated a film that is more than another movie about a couple fighting cancer: it is a monumental love story that shows endurance, even when life is most difficult. Because of Andrew Garfield and Florence Pugh’s outstanding acting methods and techniques, this narrative has never before been seen on the big screen, and is touching. This film reminds us that love can make us happy even when life gets depressing. With the amount of films about terminal cancer, it’s easy to wonder how Hollywood will keep tackling the recurrent issue of cancer in movies. These narratives serve as a reminder of the beauty that comes with living, loving, and letting go.

Psst…Interested in a more in-depth review of the A24 film? Check out this Her Campers Article by Adamari Ruelas from CU Boulder!

Hi! I’m Claralyn Manning, a San Diego native currently attending UCSB as a History major and sports reporter. As Editor in Chief and a long time HC Intern, I love combining my passions for storytelling, history, and sports while pursuing my dream of working in sports media or in teaching. When I’m not covering games or writing feature stories, you can usually find me cheering on the San Diego Padres, tanning in the sun, or spending way too much money on clothes and skincare!