“When I drive down this road,” I sang at the Bill Graham Civic Auditorium of the RAYE San Francisco concert, during the sad song, “Nightingale Lane,” as I outstretched my arm and made an unserious steering-wheel motion.
I didn’t win the Ticketmaster war before the concert. I showed up to the venue anyway, hoping someone would drop their ticket prices. After the Ticketmaster sales closed, I asked the venue information booth if the venue had any tickets. I got an obstructed view for $50, then bought a concert tee for $50. For only $100, I saw my favorite artist in concert after grinding out assignments for finals. The next couple of days, I re-listened to the recordings I took during the concert.
A few weeks later, I saw a reel of popular culture updates, one of them being RAYE at their NYC show, announcing she wouldn’t work on her next album until she was in love, since most of her discography were songs about crappy men and their mistreatment of her. It was true that most of her discography was about dealing with the aftermath of crappy men and situations, but a lot of her music described overcoming other challenges. Saying that her music revolves around negativity is reductive of her other songs about confidence and hope (also, her voice is killer).
Another thought I had was worrying whether her well-being and experience of love could be derailed if things with the person that became her muse didn’t go well. I held that thought for a second, considering if that was heading into parasocial territory. I remember after Mitski’s recent album came out, some fans were livid that Mitski wasn’t making “depressing music” anymore. Those fans probably expected Mitski to stay in the same state throughout her entire creative career. Who was I to say what was “right” for RAYE?
I thought about her music’s impact on me. I never had a song like “Ice Cream Man” speak so personally to me about an experience that most musicians don’t sing about. Although the song was beautiful, I did understand why she would want to stray from making music that centers her challenges. It’s interesting how artists share what they choose to, and how fans can absorb and put their own meaning to their art. However, there are fine lines between appreciating an artist capturing a certain feeling or experience, expecting an artist to understand what you feel, and believing you know what’s best for an artist based on what little, if any, information you have about them.
I recall that magical night of hearing her share her talents live. At one point, she turned to the left of the stage and looked up. I waved. I can’t be sure if she even saw me, but I was okay without any acknowledgement. I wanted her to stay focused.