Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
U Mass Amherst | Style

Backpack vs. Tote: The Aesthetic Debate on Campus Style

Updated Published
Priyanka Maharaj Student Contributor, University of Massachusetts - Amherst
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at U Mass Amherst chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.
international student?width=1024&height=1024&fit=cover&auto=webp&dpr=4
Zen Chung Via Unsplash

I recently made a very major decision to switch to a tote. As someone who crams everything into her bag to avoid forgetting a single thing, I fell victim to the dreaded chronic freshman backpack. And as a senior, it was getting old. When I made the switch, the clutter disappeared, and I never looked back. If you can, I highly recommend ditching the bulk—your back will thank you.  

While backpacks offer practicality, the tote bag has emerged as the ultimate symbol of effortless style, intellectualism, and adaptability. On college campuses, the tote bag isn’t just a bag; it’s a statement. A well-chosen tote says something about the person carrying it.

One of the biggest advantages of the tote bag is its versatility. Unlike the bulky, sometimes awkward backpack, a tote transitions seamlessly from class to coffee shop, from the library to off-campus. It’s casual but put-together, scholarly yet artistic. The tote bag wearer exudes a sense of intellectual cool, and those who somehow make running late look aesthetic. In the article for Grown & Flown, Helene Wingens highlights how tote bags have become a staple for students, offering practicality while reflecting personal style. She provides a well-rounded selection of totes, from luxury picks to budget-friendly finds.

Beyond its aesthetics, the tote bag aligns with the values of many college students, particularly regarding sustainability. Unlike synthetic backpacks that contribute to plastic waste, many totes are made from canvas or recycled materials, offering an eco-friendly alternative. The rise of reusable bags in everyday life has made the tote a staple for environmentally conscious students, seamlessly doubling as a grocery bag or gym carry-all. Investing in a sturdy, high-quality tote means reducing reliance on fast fashion and disposable alternatives.

MG Grad Gift Guide
markandgraham.com

Another key factor in the tote’s appeal is accessibility. Backpacks can be cumbersome—digging through multiple compartments just to find a pen is a struggle many students know too well. The sheer design of a tote allows for easy access to everything inside, decluttering your life and mind. Some may argue that the lack of structure is a downside but that’s the beauty of it all, the ability to throw it in and go! 

Of course, backpacks have their place—if you’re carrying a 15-pound biology textbook or trekking across campus in the rain, a backpack is the smarter choice. And it would be irresponsible for me to not address the possible lopsided strain on the chosen shoulder of carrying. But due to the minimalist nature of the tote, shoulder strain isn’t a problem. The tote is lightweight, stylish, and practical in ways that complement the fast-paced, dynamic lifestyle of a college student.

Ultimately, the backpack vs. tote debate is about more than just carrying books—it’s about personal expression, lifestyle, and the way we interact with our environment. The tote bag’s blend of function and fashion makes it a clear winner for students who value convenience, style, and sustainability. So, next time you see someone effortlessly slinging a tote over their shoulder, just know—it’s not just a bag; it’s making a statement. 

Can’t get enough of HC UMass Amherst? Be sure to follow us on Instagram, listen to us on Spotify, like us on Facebook, and read our latest Tweets!

Priyanka Maharaj

U Mass Amherst '21

Priyanka Maharaj is a Junior majoring in Public Policy with Biochem minor on the pre-med track. Her Campus is a creative outlet for Priyanka and allows her to interact with the UMass community in a unique way. She is very excited about this year with HC!