- Taylor
Although she may not make the best choices all the time (aka Dakota), I think she has the most authentic personality on the show. She doesn’t try to compete for attention, and she acts like a real person rather than a celebrity. She owns up to her mistakes and has made many strides towards improving herself. She is always there for her friends and supports them. I’m skeptical about how her The Bachelorette season will go, but I guess we will have to wait to see…
- Mikayla
I don’t know if it’s the fact that Mikayla was one of the only people I actually followed on TikTok before the show came out or that she is just a witty person, but Mikayla has always been one of my favorites. Again, some of the other girls come off as very calculated and I don’t think that about Mikayla. I think she is just naturally funny and is more level headed than the others. Not to mention she has experienced many traumatic things from her abuse to her chronic illness, and has become so vulnerable on the show sharing her feelings and struggles, which could help others do the same.
- Mayci
I’d like to preface this by saying that Mikayla and Mayci are pretty much tied at the top of my list, but Mikayla sticks out just a smidge more… Mayci is very much the most reasonable and responsible one. She rarely has direct personal issues with any of the other girls and seems like a good middle ground between the group. I truly think people like her make such great friends because they are always looking out for you and cheering you on. I also love her and Mikayla’s friendship!
- Miranda
At first I doubted Miranda’s intentions for joining the group after trying to avoid Taylor about the scandal but I have to say she has grown on me. She doesn’t tend to create problems within the group and again just gives off a sense of realness that some of the other girls don’t. I also respect her maturity level when it comes to her ex-husband because I think a lot of people wouldn’t be able to be friends with their ex’s new significant other, but she is genuinely a girl’s girl.Â
- Jen
Jen is someone who I go back and forth about. I really liked her this past season and think most of the time she has good intentions and just wants friendship from the girls. I go back and forth about feeling bad for her and feeling like she sometimes just ignores red flags in her husband, Zach. Although it seems as though he has made some changes, I still do not trust that man. I feel like she is really pushing the fact that he has changed but something still feels very fake about their relationship when on TV. I also think she deserved to go much farther on DWTS but was robbed.
- Jessi
Jessi does seem like a good friend most of the time but she always appears very showy to me. Everything she says is like she is talking from a script. In my opinion, her whole scandal this season was blown way out of proportion and I felt like it was brought up every second of the show. I don’t think she deserved the way Jordan was talking to her, but I also agree that it was strange that she was being so friendly with Marciano. It seems like she was using it to get more attention out of this season. But let’s be clear, I would still choose her every time over Demi though.
- Layla
At the beginning of season 3, I really did not enjoy Layla. I don’t think she causes serious problems but I do feel like she is problematic in a sneaky way, which is why she is so far down on my list. I thought the whole situation about her inviting Chase to her birthday party was really strange, not because it upset Mayci so much but just because he is literally her ex too. It just seems strange that she would want him around considering how he is Miranda’s ex husband and Layla’s ex situationship. Something just felt sneaky about it. In my mind, she is just not a girl’s girl.
- Whitney
I am so upset about Whitney because she was really making progress at the end of season 2, and I was rooting for her on DWTS. However, her behavior in season 3 caused her to lose my votes. I respect her honesty about why she came back to TSLOMW but I have no respect for the way she did it. I don’t like people who think they can just walk right back into things when they already made their decision to leave. She had no right to waltz right back in and be entitled to join the show. I think she made some progress with the girls at the very end of the season, so I hope she comes back in season 4 a lot less selfish.
- Demi
I don’t even know where to start with Demi. She has never been a favorite of mine and this season I really feel like she is trying to dig herself out of a grave she put herself into. I truly don’t understand her situation with Marciano and am not sure how to feel about it. To me she always tries to blame other people for her problems so that she is not in the wrong. She is very deceitful and has never seemed like she was a friend to anyone except Jessi, and their friendship just gave mean girl energy. I don’t feel like she should be on the show anymore, and I think others would agree.