Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
Leeds | Culture > Entertainment

Do We Really Need Another Reboot?

Ila Stephenson Student Contributor, University of Leeds
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at Leeds chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

I’m three months away from being twenty-one, which apparently means I’m old enough to have my childhood rebooted already. Harry Potter is returning this Christmas, in an upsetting clash with the usual annual reruns of the films on TV; Percy Jackson is a blond thirteen-year-old already embarking on his third quest; and Marvel is planning to recast the faces we’ve known and loved before most of us reach thirty. I hardly feel like I’ve grown out of these phases. I can be seen wandering around campus in my Slytherin scarf and gloves this very semester, so to already have the stories I grew up on repackaged for a new generation is a rather strange feeling. So, has Hollywood genuinely run out of ideas, or am I just being swayed by nostalgia? 

Of the three, the Harry Potter reboot is the one I find hardest to stomach. Perhaps I’m biased, but I can’t imagine any new version of Hogwarts living up to the one I grew up with. When I was in primary school, my big sister babysat me on the weekends, and every single time I insisted we watch Harry Potter. Again. And again. I wouldn’t be surprised if the scripts are permanently seared into her brain. The films weren’t perfect adaptations of the books, but where would be the creativity in taking no artistic liberties? Between the enchanting soundtrack that still accompanies my Christmas mornings and the VERY 2000s British wardrobe, so much of their magic belongs to that moment in time. Are a few extra scenes really enough to justify starting over?

More importantly, there’s the issue of the notorious political nightmare that is J.K. Rowling. Her increasingly vocal opposition to transgender rights has gone well beyond controversial tweets from her oversized living room. In 2024, Rowling donated £70,000 to For Women Scotland, which pursued a legal challenge over the definition of ‘woman’ under the Equality Act; she has also established a fund supporting legal cases over sex-based rights. As of October 2026, she published another essay reaffirming her position. This isn’t simply a case of separating an author’s personal beliefs from her work, especially when such beliefs are being financially and politically backed. HBO has made Rowling an executive producer, and Forbes estimated she could earn around $20 million a year from the adaptation, on top of her estimated $1.2 billion net worth. Does she really need another enormous paycheck from us?

Interestingly, several people actively working on the series have publicly disagreed with her. Bel Powley (Petunia Dursley) strongly disagrees with Rowling’s views on gender, while John Lithgow (Dumbledore) called them “ironic and inexplicable”. In a Vanity Fair interview on 10 November, Paapa Essiedu (Snape) reaffirmed his support for trans people but said he didn’t want to speak on Rowling’s politics; apparently, he believes the books’ messages about acceptance are worth revisiting. And yet, the production still benefits from their bigoted creator. Black Mirror director Ally Pankiw and Loki director Kate Herron turned down offers to direct episodes because of anti-trans activism. Pankiw argued that refusing to contribute to the funding of transphobia was an easy decision to make. So surely, we have a right to question others’ decision to join the series while publicly distancing themselves from the profiteer?

To everybody’s relief, the original Golden Trio have all made their distaste towards Rowling’s views clear, expressing their support for the transgender community. Daniel Radcliffe recently admitted he wasn’t sure he’d watch the reboot, though his reasoning was less political than mine: the man simply doesn’t watch much television. 

With the benefit of age, I will be the first to admit that Harry Potter has aged poorly, with a shocking amount of racial stereotyping throughout. For more on this, I point you towards Kayhan Nejad’s paper ‘Literal and Metaphorical: Racial Themes in Harry Potter’. Nejad points out how, “In typical Eurocentric fashion, these assignments range from white (good) to black (evil)”, with Dumbledore’s first name (Albus), meaning ‘white’ in Latin and Voldemort being “colloquially referred to as the ‘Dark Lord’”. I mean really, what sort of name is ‘Kingsley Shacklebolt’ for one of the few Black characters in  a position of authority? It’s particularly absurd to me that a franchise so concerned with prejudice and intolerance is written by a woman so bigoted. 

I’m not saying we should stop loving the stories we grew up with – I’m currently planning another rewatch and I certainly won’t be throwing away my House scarf anytime soon. Though cherishing something that shaped your childhood is different from actively supporting another money-grabbing adaptation of it. Give us something new!

Percy Jackson has been a slightly different story reboot-wise. I adored the books as a Greek-mythology fanatic, though I was never too attached to the films beyond the 2010s nostalgia. I still can’t listen to Poker Face without thinking of the Lotus Casino, and I’ve never seen iPods the same since. I only got around to the Disney+ series this summer, fittingly on the beautiful Greek island of Spetses with my flatmates. As we were all childhood fans, we were pleasantly surprised despite the jarringly age-accurate casting. Rick Riordan himself has been heavily involved in ensuring the series remains faithful to the books, which I would say has been a success. The films left plenty of room for improvement. 

Still, I was surprised by how quickly the franchise returned to our screens, premiering just ten years after the second film. Although I understand it, I was disappointed by how unnecessarily watered down the series feels. In The Lightning Thief, Percy’s discovery that his stepfather has been physically abusing his mother is a significant moment, though the show tones down his behaviour considerably. On top of this, the characters frequently recognise the danger they’re in before even encountering it. As a reader, I remember much of the excitement coming from discovering the monsters and their intentions as Percy did, whereas the series suffers from having the characters explain exactly what’s about to happen before it does. I’m not asking to see twelve-year-olds subjected to gore, but I’d like to fear for their lives every now and then. The books may have been written for children, but they certainly weren’t afraid to explore the darker subject matter that Greek myth contains. The gods of Olympus were cruel and the quests dangerous, and Riordan captured this even when retelling it for children.

What I would really have liked if they were going to bring Percy, Grover and Annabeth back to our screens so soon, was an adaptation aimed at those of us who grew up reading the books as they were being released and are now in our twenties. I’m not suggesting that Percy Jackson should become an adult franchise, but I would love to see a version that embraces the darker aspects of Greek mythology that made the books so compelling. Of course, it’s entirely possible that I’m simply no longer the intended audience. A new generation will spend its summers pretending to be children of Greek gods, as I did (sorry, Mum, for the day I was pretending to be in Cabin Four and got grass and soil all over my clothes). I can’t begrudge them that, even if I wish the series had grown up a little with us. 

Marvel is where I struggle to be reasonable. The MCU was a huge part of my adolescence thanks to my brother, but it’s followed me even more intensely into adulthood. In my second year at university, my flatmates and I bonded over watching the Marvel films in order with Freshers’ Fair discounted pizza. It was obvious how much affection all of us still had for the films, no matter how big of a fan each of us was. So, naturally, Marvel has decided it’s time to start Avengers, Disassemble. Following Avengers: Secret Wars in 2027, Marvel Studios president Kevin Feige plans a “reset”, with new X-Men actors and the eventual recasting of Tony Stark and Steve Rogers. Feige doesn’t seem brave enough to call it a reboot, even. 

Wasn’t the entire point of Avengers: Endgame that these characters’ stories had finally come to an end? Tony Stark sacrificed himself to save the universe, Steve Rogers got his happy (selfish) ending (don’t bring this up to me), and I struggled to keep a dry eye during the Far From Home slideshow, even. Did the amount of tissues gone through mean nothing? Seven years later, Robert Downey Jr. is returning to the MCU as Doctor Doom in Avengers: Doomsday. Yes, he’s playing a different character, but it’s hard to miss the appeal of bringing back such a familiar face. I appreciate that comic books have been reinventing their heroes for decades, but the MCU has spent nearly twenty years building these versions, played by actors who have become practically inseparable from their characters. Marvel has an enormous catalogue of stories left to explore from the tens of thousands of Marvel comics in existence. I’d much rather see them develop these new stories than spend the next twenty years trying to recreate the success of the first twenty. If everyone can eventually come back, what’s the point of ever saying goodbye?

After all that ranting, I have to admit that yes, nostalgia probably is clouding my judgement a little. Had I been born ten years later, I might be thrilled at the prospect of a new Hogwarts. Percy Jackson proves that revisiting a story can be worthwhile when an earlier adaptation left much to be desired, but why must everything successful eventually be made again? And in the case of Harry Potter, my objections go considerably further than missing Alan Rickman. I think we’re allowed to question where our money goes, even when the thing being sold has enormous sentimental value. Hollywood hasn’t run out of stories, it’s simply discovered how much easier it is to sell us ones we already love. 

Editor: Tamima Islam

Senior Editor for Her Campus at Leeds
English Literature & Philosophy student and music lover!!