Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
Illinois State | Culture > Entertainment

My Thoughts on Dancing With The Stars As a First Time Watcher

Lillian Kelch Student Contributor, Illinois State University
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at Illinois State chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

Throughout my time as a student in my first year of college, I have been struggling to stick to a routine. To help combat this issue, I have started watching shows that air on specific days so I have something to keep me motivated to do tasks on certain days. This weekly system has changed how I manage my time: 

  • Monday: 1000 Pound Sisters
  • Tuesday: Dancing With The Stars
  • Friday: Hell’s Kitchen

While I first used television as a reward system after completing my homework, I have recently found myself eagerly waiting for Dancing With The Stars in particular. I’ve been sucked into the excitement, constantly voting for my favorite dances and watching out for what the theme and songs will be for the following week. Now, with the semi-finals just around the corner, I want to share my thoughts on the show as a whole, and what media culture surrounding it. As a first-time watcher, I am hoping to offer a fresh perspective that is free from the bias of previous seasons. This does contain spoilers, so please read with caution. 

Firstly, the culture shock of how TikTok reacts to contestants was a lot to get used to, and I’m not completely sure I’m acclimated to it all yet. Going into my first ever watch of Dancing With The Stars, I expected it to be more about being excited about the choreography and the colorful costumes. Instead, I’ve seen debates over who deserves to be competing and even on the show in the first place. 

According to the internet, it’s bad to have had dance experience prior to coming on the show. 

Apparently it’s bad to have been a previous dancer on the show. In my opinion, the title Dancing With The Stars does not presuppose that all contestants must be beginners in dance. It’s a bit ludicrous to expect everyone to be on the same level and I don’t think that such a thing will realistically happen on a show that pulls celebrities from all across the entertainment industry. When people online bring up past dance experience, they are usually using it as an excuse to undermine what frontrunners Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Dewan have accomplished within the competition. Their dances are complex, high-level routines that take immense athleticism and dedication so, regardless of their background, it feels unfair that their hard work is being dismissed simply because they aren’t starting from scratch. 

I have also seen a double standard when it comes to this. For example, Amber Glenn is an Olympic gold medalist and figure skater so she obviously came into the competition with a background in posture, turning skills, and dancing properly to a rhythm, but this is never brought up in discussions of unfairness on Tiktok. 

Alongside the debates over dance experience, another recurring narrative on my For You Page is the claim that the voting is rigged and that the judges and producers have their minds made up before America casts any ballots. As someone who diligently texts in my votes every Tuesday night, it can be frustrating to see people constantly dismiss the results of an elimination as predetermined. 

I think a way that this could be remedied– or at least stop people from assuming that the system is rigged, would be for the show to display the number of votes each contestant receives from viewers voting on the website or texting their favorite contestant to 21523. 

Even if they don’t want to give straight numbers, converting to basic percentages would go a long way in sharing what the public actually thinks. Not only would it build more trust between the audience and the producers, it would be interesting to see as a viewer. You’d be able to see how your personal favorites stack up against what the rest of the country enjoys. 

Something that has been irking me on social media is how everyone is blown out of proportion and everyone reacts to everything very personally. A massive portion of Dancing With The Stars Tok is dedicated to dissecting every word judge Carrie Ann Inaba says to the contestants and their pros. This reached a boiling point during Super Bowl Night when Carrie Ann called out pro Jenna Johnson and Harry Shum Jr. for an illegal lift during a samba, even pulling out the rulebook to define what a lift was. 

What followed was a prime example of how out of hand the surrounding media culture can get. Jenna Johnson’s husband, fellow pro Val Chmerkovskiy, uploaded a since-deleted post referencing Will Smith slapping Chris Rock at the Oscars in defense of his wife. The remark crossed a major line leading BBC Studios to suspend him for a week and force his celebrity partner, Jenna Dewan, to dance with Alan Bersten instead. While Val apologized, the whole situation highlighted for me how hypersensitive the environment around the show has become. 

Because fans dissect literally every single thing, I wish the pros and judges were able to give honest critiques without facing immediate backlash from the audience. This is also supported by the fact that the crowd boos whenever Carrie Ann Inaba provides criticism but they don’t for the other judges. 

A major reason that I loved when Shirley Ballas, a renowned ballroom champion known as the “Queen of Latin,” was a guest judge during Horror Movie Night was because she wasn’t afraid to give harsh criticism or low scores. To me, constructive criticism is how people grow and giving people the same score over and over isn’t necessarily visually showing them that they still have things that could be improved in terms of their technique. Viewers seem divided on how the show should even be judged and run in general because some want strict ballroom rules enforced while others want it treated as purely entertainment. 

Despite the online chaos, judging debates, and weekly controversies, I am completely hooked. What started as a trick for me to get my homework done has turned into a highlight of my week. Stepping into the world that is Dancing With The Stars has shown me that it is so much more than I thought it was. As we head into the semi-finals, I am excited to see who takes home the Mirrorball, even if I am still struggling to wrap my head around the comment sections along the way.

Lillian Kelch

Illinois State '30

Hi! My name is Lillian!

I am a freshman at ISU majoring in English. This is my first year with Her Campus and I am very excited for the years to come! In my free time, I like to read, play video games, work on legos, and listen to music. My favorite song right now is I Know The End by Phoebe Bridgers.