Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
FSU | Culture

‘The Pitt’ vs. ‘Grey’s Anatomy’: Is This the Next Big Medical Drama?

Adria Pike Student Contributor, Florida State University
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at FSU chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

Since the arrival of The Pitt on Max, medical drama fans have a new show to tune into! With 15 episodes depicting a 15-hour emergency room shift, this series brings us behind the scenes in this high-stakes environment. Each episode takes place in a single hour, showing the intense realism of a healthcare worker.

By portraying the urgency of hospital life, The Pitt is already earning comparisons to Grey’s Anatomy. Though The Pitt focuses less on hospital drama and more on the mental toll performing procedures can have on medical professionals, it will surely speak to the same core audience. 

Grey’s Anatomy is a 21-season series that focuses on the daily life of Meredith Grey, a talented surgeon at Seattle Grace Hospital with an emotionally conflicting life. It tells the story of the complexities of performing life-or-death operations and the relationships that form in the hospital. Viewers experience feelings of heartbreak, adrenaline, euphoria, and even fear as they watch her life unfold.

The same rollercoaster of emotions can be found in The Pitt, making it a wildly successful streaming series. The show attracts those who crave drama, vital decision-making, and deep, complicated feelings.

It doesn’t entertain as much relational drama as Grey’s Anatomy, though. It’s meant to focus on how procedures unfold in the ER. We see how each case affects the psyche of the doctor who encounters it and how the doctor transforms mentally every minute they’re working.

As they endure the hardships of the ER, we see the characters grow and change in real-time. What’s a good medical drama without any character development? We follow them as each person faces both personal and professional challenges.

We notice how this kind of environment can take a toll on mental health, which sets The Pitt apart from other medical shows. There’s no sugarcoating in this ER. Rather, it offers a unique perspective, leaving the audience utterly invested in the well-being of these professionals.

As we watch these procedures unfold, we get a (mostly) medically accurate look at how things go down in a hospital. Most medical dramas don’t have this element, which adds an extra level of intensity to the show. It also creates an immersive experience for viewers — it makes you feel like you like you’re standing right there, experiencing everything with the doctors!

The Pitt is known to resonate with the audience, so much so that people are already asking for more seasons. It’s not just a show; it’s an experience that affects its audience at a personal level. Viewers experience each moment of these doctors’ shifts. We observe the raw essence of hospital life by feeling every emotion, loss, and tough call. Everything seems amplified in this chaotic, fast-paced environment.

As a Grey’s Anatomy fan, I feel a sense of loyalty to the show, especially my girl Meredith. However, The Pitt brings something fresh to the table. It offers another glimpse into the lives of healthcare workers, not just surgeons, and a seemingly raw view of their emotions and personal mentality during an ER shift.

The chaos and intensity of each scene sucks you in, making for an amazing show for binging. If you’re looking for a medical drama that gives you a deeper understanding of what doctors really go through, The Pitt is an experience you won’t want to miss!

Want to see more HCFSU? Be sure to like us on Facebook and follow us on Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, and Pinterest!

Hi, I’m Adria! I’m a freshman at Florida State University, currently majoring in Public Relations, with plans to pursue a dual degree in Marketing.

I am from Bradenton, Fl, so you can typically find me at the beach or at a local coffee shop! Outside of school, music and church are big aspects of my life. Also, I love meeting new people and engaging in new activities with my friends!

In the future, I would like to pursue a career in public relations. I hope to work in beauty, entertainment or tourism industries. I am excited to grow my writing skills through Her Campus, and I am thankful for the opportunity to be a part of this amazing chapter!