“The fashion is being circular,” they say, whilst buying new clothes every week. Let’s be real. I bought outerwear because what I already had looked outdated. This cycle of buying new clothes results from a culture of overconsumption. The new generations are seeking another way to stop this unsustainable habit through ‘thrift shopping’.Â
According to ThredUp, the global secondhand market reached $257 billion by 2025 and is expected to reach $393 billion in 2030, growing twice as fast as the overall apparel industry. It looks amazing, right? But is it really, really sustainable for the world?
To be realistic, it is impossible to track all the items’ sustainability impacts due to several reasons – mainly of disclosed primary resource data. There is, however, a method to assess secondhand products’ impacts by how consumers behave.Â
Before diving into checking the benefits of the second-hand market, some terms are important to understand:
- CT (Circular Thrift): a business model that focuses on a circular fashion ecosystem, founded by Lisa Goldsand – practiced through community clothing swaps, workshops in reuse & repair; all focused on reducing textile waste
- Blue water consumption: volume of freshwater taken from surface water and groundwater sources for various uses, including irrigation, manufacturing, and household activities
The research method was retrieved through collecting data records of clothing units donated and trashed within the period of time.
Examine the Environmental & Social benefits in tangible impacts
The circular fashion system is divided into environmental and social impacts, as it influences different areas. Environmental covers the impacts on nature, while social refers to stakeholders who account for the impacts of products – workers, consumers, and society.
By using the CT research method, about 10,772 apparel units were collected within the research time. From the collected units, 97.87% were kept in use for primary purposes like donation to the local community and recycle/upcycle adoption. This also helps lower blue water consumption than new product purchase.
In the social aspect, it resulted in 45.86% (6,695 units) of the collected items being given back to the local community. This includes a resource center for immigrants, a local elementary school for children of SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program), reused clothing swaps, and non-profit clothing stores. The society showed willingness and contribution to reduce textile waste, thus initiating the circular thrift.
But what if, under the scenario that thrifted items could partially replace new products (which also means a 50% displacement rate), would actually happen?
- Almost 164,000 L of fresh water can be saved
This is equivalent to a person’s water use for one year and five months
- 6,000 kg CO2e of GHG (Greenhouse gas emissions) can be prevented
This estimates the emissions of a car that travels for one year and four months, riding thirty-one miles per day
- 47,000 MJ (primary energy demand) can be reduced
This equals fifteen months of electricity use in an average U.S. home
So… what would you do?
With all the research and practices, the results could be extracted only when countries apply this CT business concept under the condition that businesses and locals actually participate. I personally see that it is almost impossible to change the fashion industry for now.
I want to say that not every purchase is wrong or irresponsible, but not being responsible for your belongings could result in worse damage to the world. This is not only important for the consumers, but the businesses also hold a great accountability in this consumption loop.
Do not feel unmotivated because you feel like you are the only one doing so. Consistency is a game-changer.