When someone’s work means a lot to us, does that give us any claim on their attention?
Picture spotting your favourite actor in a café. You’ve watched their interviews, followed
their career and imagined what you would say if you ever met them. Now they’re sitting a
few tables away, eating lunch. Do you approach?
I can understand the excitement; I’ve felt it myself! Someone’s work might have helped you
through a difficult time, shaped your taste or become part of your friendships. Perhaps their
film is the one you and your friends endlessly quote, or their album reminds you of a
particular summer. Meeting them can feel like a chance to acknowledge something that has
mattered to you.
Except they don’t know any of that. For you, this could be a moment you’ll remember for
years. For them, it could be another interruption to their lunch, a source of annoyance or an
inconvenience in their day.
Interviews, podcasts and social media let us become familiar with people who don’t even
know we exist. We recognise their laugh, know the names of their pets and hear stories about
their childhood. It’s easy to see how a parasocial relationship develops: a connection that
feels personal but only runs in one direction.
I’d call what can happen next the intimacy–access fallacy: confusing how well we feel we
know someone with how much access they owe us. Because does choosing fame mean
choosing constant availability?
There is an argument that fan support helps sustain a career. People buy the tickets, stream
the music and recommend the work. That support matters and enables celebrities to enjoy the
lifestyle they live. But does buying a ticket also buy access to someone’s private time? When
does appreciation become an expectation that they should always stop, smile and make us
feel special?
Chappell Roan brought this tension into focus when she spoke publicly about harassment,
unwanted physical contact and the boundaries she wanted respected outside her work. The
response raised a familiar argument: she chose this life.
But how much does that choice include? Does wanting to perform mean agreeing to be
approached wherever you go? Can someone enjoy connecting with an audience and still want
to have dinner without being interrupted?
I think most of us can recognise the difference between a premiere or signing and a family
meal. The harder part is accepting that when an unexpected opportunity presents itself, we
might know it isn’t the ideal moment, but we also know we may never get another chance.
Then there’s the photograph. Would we still approach someone if we couldn’t post about it
afterwards? A photograph can be a lovely reminder of an encounter. But still, I wonder
whether we sometimes become so focused on proving the meeting happened that we barely experience it. Do we want to tell someone what their work meant to us, have a conversation,
or leave with something other people will recognise as impressive?
I don’t think wanting to meet someone you admire automatically makes you entitled. I’d
probably feel the same excitement, rehearse a sentence in my head and immediately forget it
if they looked in my direction. But the strength of that feeling doesn’t create an obligation for
the other person.
A considerate encounter must leave room for refusal. Asking politely means being prepared
to accept an answer you didn’t want. Someone declining a photograph might disappoint you
without having done anything wrong. But it is certainly their right not to perform for you.
So, let’s walk back into that café. Your favourite actor is still a few tables away, finishing
their lunch. You might approach, or you might decide to leave them alone.
If you do ask, perhaps the most revealing part of the encounter is how you respond when they
say no.