“Restoring Trust, Managing Transformation: A United Nations That Delivers for All” was the chosen theme to lead the general debate of the 81st session of the United Nations General Assembly. Awaited with high anticipation all year long for both heads of state and the international community, the diplomatic discussion gathered all the UN’s 193 member states between 22 and 28 September 2026.
Throughout those six days, delegations brought up particular perspectives regarding the world’s contemporaryity most concerning issues . Of all, a specific matter, however, has drawn particular attention to the General Assembly Hall in New York City.“Concessions to the law of the stronger have surpassed all limits […] It’s the complete breakdown of politics in an interdependent world”, declared the delegation of the Federative Republic of Brazil during its opening speech for the general debate. His Excellency Lula’s words reveal an unsettling and increasing concern that has not only been perceived by Brazil,but also by all nations across the world: the United Nations, as a multilateral organ in its principles, has no functional authority left in current worldwide political layout.
This phenomenon does not restrict itself to international entities only. On the other hand, as part of what guides a way of doing geopolitics, it exposes a gradual wear of international law as humanity has known for decades. In the light of it, foreign relationships have changed, and so has the nullifying of global rules. Therefore, the inquiry remains: to what extent is it still an instrument of influence of any kind?
What Does International Law Stand For?
As an indispensable component of International Affairs, International Law is universally recognized as the set of rules and principles responsible for regulating foreign relations between state members of the international community. The term has, as its major priority, the duty to successfully fulfil the seven fundamental principles proposed by the Charter of the United Nations – originally conceived in 1945 -, as formally stated in Chapter 1, envisaged in Article 2 in the document.
International Law first appears in History during the 17th Century. Back to this historical background , when Europe was the setting for numerous rivalries – : mainly brought about by religious divergences between Catholics and Protestants, but also caused by both commercial and territorial dispute and the struggle over political supremacy over the continent, various European nations faced the so called Thirty Years´War (1618-1648), an imminent, highly devastating warfare. In the light of such escalated tension, “Peace of Westphalia” emerged on 24 October 1648, a Treaty of Peace signed between the nations involved, that had formally put an end to the prolonged conflict once and for all.
Established over 300 years ago, the settlement is recognized as the very first effort towards the standardising of common, universal patterns of conduct among Modern States, as it is claimed to be the emergence of International Affairs as well.
The Treaty of Peace redesigned Europe in terms of power and foreign politics: primarily, it declared sovereignty to European states, proposed the non-interference in domestic business and established the equality of rights and duties followed by nations.
Aiming at limiting modern states’ actions, in terms of hegemony, and guaranteeing the balance of international power, contemporary International Law is a reflection of what was constructed four centuries ago. Nowadays, its vital role in reinforcing conciliation and attempting to promote harmony between divergent interests among nations is, more than ever, still crucial to the international community.
New Pieces On The Chess Board: A Change of Traditional World Display
After two brutal World Wars that exhausted the globe, the 20th Century was protagonized by a non-direct geopolitical conflict between two major political powerhouses carrying the most influence over the globe: on one side, there it was the United States of America, a right-wing nation, the face of a capitalist ideology; on the other, the Soviet Union emerged as a left-wing state, protecting socialist values and attempting to beat American’s rising sway.
This period is acknowledged as the Cold War (1947-1991) – forty-four years followed by a bipolar, polarized world order, in which political power was relatively balanced between the U.S.A and the USSR. On 9 November 1989, the collapse of the Berlin Wall – originally built by East Germany, allies with the Soviet Union – symbolised the end of the conflict, with the permanent dissolution of the USSR in 1991. This chain of historical events led to a brand new stage of International Affairs: the United States had achieved utmost hegemony, tied to a capitalist economical and political blueprint. It highlighted the start of the New World Order.
For many years, American worldwide hegemony was lasting – and so was the unipolar order established so far. The advent of the 21st Century, however, exposed how rapid the rise of a powerhouse can be limited, as, due to economical, political and technological phenomena, worldwide geopolitics started to evolve once again.
Brazilian geographer and geography scholar, Milton Santos, emphasizes the relevance of Globalization towards this process. “The fact is that the world has become one, thanks to this very same technique which, moreover, is not the same everywhere, nor does it serve everyone in the same way”, stated Milton in “Toward an Other Globalization: From the Single Thought to Universal Conscience”, a cultural work of his own, first published in 2000. In contemporaneity, its occurrence materializes the growing integration among states, just as their unavoidable interdependence of cultural, economical, technological, social and mainly political features.
As formerly quoted, Globalization does not happen under the same circumstances to every nation. Although it does democratize a global integration, allowing countries to exchange their particularities, it contributes to the widening of international inequality between mundial major powers and peripheral states. The phenomenon, simultaneously, means both inclusion and exclusion, which reveals the complexity of international affairs nowadays.
A concrete consequence is reflected by the redesign of structures of geopolitical power: the world order has been internationally recognized as in a state of transition between unipolarity to multipolarity, modification that implies the rise of brand new regional political actors. Rather than accepting American hegemony, these growing nations’ aim is the same – disputing global influence and attempting to defy traditional western domination.
Over the past few decades, Asian powerhouse China has exponentially ascended, both economically and politically, becoming the United States’ ultimate foe. Moreover, a former socialist enemy, Russia has found its way to bounce back into the international system and now fights for concretizing its space among Chinese influence.
Regional alliances are part of the picture as well. Developing nations, which commonly share a historical background permeated by colonialism, imperialism and economic dependency, strategically align in order to fortify both continental cooperation and strength, at the same time they put into question imperialist and hegemonic values formerly diffused. The BRICS, a concrete example of modern multipolarity, arouses under these circumstances, as it is possible to recognize the international effort between emerging countries to resist unipolarity. It denotes the surface of what is known as the Global South.
In the light of Multipolar Order, International Law faces countless obstacles towards its fulfilment. Once global power becomes highly decentralized and conflict of interests between nations characterises a stiff, unpredictable competition, concerns over legal frameworks previously established are raised.
A Challenging Dilemma
The legitimacy of International Law has become a particular conundrum – repeatedly a matter of discussion among the international community. The fragmentation of traditional hierarchy of power exposes how the application of universal rules is a thin – and most times an overridable – line, specially for those who, historically, bear the fortune of utmost authority.
In an interview with Her Campus, Iranian economist and specialist in international business, Beny Fard, draws attention to the subject. “Whoever has greater power ends up influencing, more forcefully, which rules apply to themselves”, he punctuates. Although, on paper, International Law evenly serves nations in terms of equal duties and responsibilities towards the international community, performing as a neutral legal mechanism of juridical defense, its reality has drastically changed – and now faces multiple obstacles.
The economist attributes the phenomenon to transformations in International Affairs, as geopolitical approaches between states have become highly conflicting and defiant, taking into account the reorganisation of the world map’s zones of influence. The more conflicts of interest get each time more escalated, the challenging it is to enforce the legal commitment to universal rules. “The deterioration of multilateralism and globalization means that legal certainty is increasingly weak”, Beny explains.
To shed light on the matter, International Law has lost its former ultimate authority and it is now perceived, by heads of state and governmental figures, as a legal mechanism that serves the law of selectivity – imposed by powerhouses with greater dominance over smaller states, those who do not benefit from the same influence to respond in kind. In this political game, what has the final word to determine whether or not the rules are going to be fulfilled are geopolitical demands.
Article 2(4) of the United Nations Charter clearly establishes that: “All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations.” On 3 January 2026, however, President of the United States of America, Donald Trump, willfully intervened militarily in Venezuela under the pretext of countering narco-terrorism conspiratorial charges. The action resulted in the capture and arrest of Venezuelan President, Nicolás Maduro, and his wife, Cilia Flores.
The American president claimed the necessity to fight illegal drug transportation in Latin America at all costs. But his eyes were set on another ultimate interest – managing access to the Venezuelan oil industry. The occurrence is a solid example of how effortless it is for a powerhouse, such as the U.S, to overrule International Law when it is convenient to its benefits. “The great powers that exert influence over other nations, whether over their sphere of dominance or through geopolitical and economic interests, and then you have those nations’ zones of interest, which cause there to be more pressure or less pressure through multilateral bodies”, reinforces Beny.
Beyond this background, another political matter calls International Law into question. State sovereignty is recognized as one of the main fundamental pillars that rules International Affairs manners, as it declares independence and authority to govern both the territory and the people of a country without external interference.
In an interdependent world, however, this principle has effectively come into conflict with international norms. “Rarely do you have a great nation, a power, allowing the creation of any kind of law or norm that ends up negatively impacting its own nation in any aspect”, argues the specialist. The way Beny sees it, most times, states demonstrate willingness to cooperate with foreign demands – as long as they do not interfere in the accomplishment of domestic agendas – nations’ supreme priority. “The head of state will always defend that country and that country’s sovereignty, seeking to respect, in some way, international rules and treaties, but if there is a clash, a conflict between international norms and the defense of domestic law and of the sovereignty of his own people, he will inevitably choose his own”, he concludes.
In this context, International Law has the potential to serve, once again, as a juridical tool in favor of the most powerful nations. When national interests are greater than the international ones, heads of state of powerhouses end up choosing to apply the norms of multilateral bodies in order to pressure adversaries, potential foes – or even allies – into obeying domestic requests that do not necessarily correspond to their own.
It is the materialization of an explicit imbalance between multilateral cooperation and sovereign duties: one, inevitably, comes into conflict with the other – and in the midst of it all, formerly established norms find their legitimacy compromised.
Multilateralism: A Systemic Crisis
“The pillars of multilateralism are being eroded”, Brazilian most recently reelected – on 25 October – President, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, evoked during his speech for the UNGA 81 morning session. Traditionally, the delegation is recognized for its role in opening UN debates, given its conciliatory posture over history. The pronunciation is not restricted to Lula’s perception of international relations – among most heads of state, it is commonly agreed that current diplomatic mechanisms of harmony are damaged.
Iranian specialist Beny Fard sheds light on the matter. “We are reaching, in my view, the end of the cycle that was built after 1945. That cycle that was built after the Second World War is ending”. The following decades of World War II (1939-1945) were preceded by a greater necessity for a legal, judicial guarantee of both international stability and foreign diplomatic exchange between the nations. It is under these circumstances that the United Nations is founded, subsequent to the end of the warfare: currently the world’s main international organization, the body aims at achieving peace, justice, equality and solidarity to a global extent.
For over eight decades, the UN has been claimed and pictured as capable of such. However, in the light of the escalation of armed conflicts, effective wars and rivalry between powerhouses, its effectiveness has been universally called into question, as many argue that the organ is more of a symbolic tool rather than an efficacious one. “It means that what was built 80 years ago is ceasing to exist gradually, but now more accelerated by Donald Trump 2. And when you have ruptures, they are not cause, they are effect”, he concludes.
As a direct consequence, the institution now faces a massive lack of legitimacy, at the same time its authority is inappropriately abused. Since International Law does not dispose of a centralised coercive application, being at the mercy of states’ willingness to fulfil or not its principles, its possibility to exert influence over countries moves and decisions towards the international community ends up being extremely limited.
A concrete example is materialized by the UN Security Council veto power, a right solely granted to permanent members of the organ. There are currently five countries that occupy the position: China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States. The committee’s hierarchy display makes it more challenging and conflicting in terms of finding a common balance between both opposite geopolitical interests and competition – which exposes its contradictory functioning. In this context, instead of serving as a resourceful maintainer of resolution, it turns out as a restrainer on its own, as the veto allows the accomplishment of partial goals.
Allied to that, the rise of unilateralism in international relations has threatened mutual cooperation towards the fulfillment of the laws universally established. Once great powers concentrate enough political influence to act on their own, according to their own demands, the overruling of its principles is perceived as a necessary move to achieve a greater purpose.
A Historical Burden Long Carried
The phenomena reinforce a hierarchical pattern settled long before.
Dated back from the 15th to 17th Century, the Age of Discovery marked the dawn of early globalization: a period characterized by European cultural, economic, political and social dominance over Latin American territory and societies, legitimized through the long-lasting practice of colonialism. Later on, post World War II, neocolonialism emerged as a modern expression of power, this time, beneficial to former imperialist powerhouses, as American, Asian and mainly African states suffered the consequences from a renewed exploitation and domination mechanism.
Nowadays, the geopolitical setting has drastically changed. However, little has political subordination changed – instead, it has only switched covers.
The nations that once shared a colonial background are the same ones that suffer the most from the selectivity in the use of International Law, as well as the inability of international organs to counter diplomatic warfares. “We are called to choose between multilateralism or unilateralism, democracy or extremism, sovereignty or subordination. These choices require courage, political will and clarity of objectives”, the Brazilian delegation pleaded during the general debate of the United Nations General Assembly, an example of how current diplomacy is predominantly coercive.
Although, on paper, all member states of the international community have their right to evenly participate in diplomatic matters and decisions insured, the Global South is most definitely affected negatively when it comes to validating this symbolical resource. At the end of the day, the international common welfare prevails according to the standards of dominant countries – and so do juridical mechanisms, given the lack of space and effectiveness for peripheral agents’ perspectives to be not only heard, but truly understood by the most powerful nations.
Contemporary Values, Traditional Rules: Towards A Fair Balance
International Law faces a state of transition in view of present geopolitical display, as it is constantly being put into question by both heads of state and the international society. In times of profound change, even conventional standards, perceived as immutable due to its credibility, are open to change.
Undeniably, the set of norms the world has known for decades, in its primitive molds, is no longer perceived as legitimate, as its balance is now shifting. The escalation of modern conflicts, allied to the incompatibility of interests between nations, is proof that International Law needs to go through a process of adaptation to the new worldwide order currently settled, in order to promote and strengthen both global governance and conciliation.
On the other hand, multilateralism is a key factor to international engagement commitment. Mutual cooperation among states is the fundamental principle that improves foreign relations, maintaining compromise and deference for ultimate, legit rules – as well as countering its machination and consequent overriding.
———————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————
The article above was edited by Ana Rita Rodrigues Fernandes.
Liked this type of content? Check Her Campus Cásper Líbero home page for more!