Spoiler alert: Spoilers for The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping film and book follow. “Haymitch didn’t drink enough.” That was pretty much the first thing Hunger Games fans blurted out after finally getting to see Haymitch’s life before Katniss in Sunrise on the Reaping, which hit theaters on Nov. 20. After Catching Fire, fans of the Suzanne Collins series (and the hit movies) knew Haymitch’s Hunger Games were a doozy, being the 50th Games and the 2nd Quarter Quell. And every Quarter Quell had its “thing” — this one being that there were twice the number of tributes with 48. Haymitch was “reaped” alongside one more boy and two girls from District 12.
Sunrise on the Reaping is a true prequel. The book was written in March 2025 by the queen herself, Suzanne Collins, and now, a little more than a year later, we finally have the movie. Francis Lawrence is back in the director’s chair, because at this point, he basically is The Hunger Games franchise.
Fans have been counting down to this movie for what feels like forever. The casting? Nailed it. The nostalgia? Through the roof. And the callbacks to the OG franchise? Absolute perfection. The only thing people were raising eyebrows at was how they’d turn a seriously brutal book into something PG-13. Spoiler alert: They somehow pulled it off, but fans were left feeling that major scenes were missed or changed. Here are some of the differences between The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping book versus the movie.
- Maysilee & Maritte killing the gamemakers
-
This is the scene that had fans yelling at their screens. In the book, District 12’s Maysilee Donnor and District 4’s Career tribute Maritte actually team up and take out three Gamemakers who were in the arena trying to patch up the damage caused by Haymitch. This had fans upset, as this is such an important scene explaining why both tributes end up getting hunted and killed by mutts.
- Haymitch’s training score
-
Although training scenes were shown a bit, fans never see Haymitch get his iconic training score. When Haymitch is being evaluated, he decides to antagonize and mock the Gamemakers rather than showing off a skill. This results in him getting a 1. Fans would’ve loved to see this in the movie, as it has been compared to Katniss shooting an arrow at the Gamemakers and receiving an 11. “Nice shooting, sweetheart.” Like mentor, like tribute.
- Silka eating the chocolate
-
This book scene had everyone sobbing, and I was right there with them. Silka is portrayed as this terrifying Career from District 1 that viewers are all afraid of. Towards the end of the games, Haymitch is hiding in a tree with Silka obliviously crying below. He drops chocolates he got from sponsors, and she shows her vulnerable side as she falls asleep. Why did they choose to leave this out? We will never know, but it would’ve been the perfect reminder that these Careers are also just kids fighting for their lives.
- Haymitch watching Lucy Gray’s games
-
Lionsgate In the film, we thankfully got a mention of Lucy Gray by Snow himself. In the book, before Haymitch’s victory crowning, Snow makes Haymitch watch footage of himself and Lucy Gray, the District 12 Covey girl he was in love with. This sparked many fan theories about why Snow would show Haymitch his deepest secret. Fans thought it was to see if Haymitch recognized her because Snow was still obsessed. This scene was cut from the movie, but we did get a different version where Snow just straight-up asked Haymitch if he knew of her.
- Haymitch & Maysilee scenes
-
This one had fans extremely upset. The heart of this book was Haymitch and Maysilee’s relationship, and most of it was cut from the movie. We only get a few scenes of them together, and never see their relationship blossom like how it did in the book. Cue the quote: “Goodbye, Maysilee Donner, who I loathed, then grudgingly respected, then loved,” Haymitch said in part in the book. “A sister is someone you fight with and fight for. Tooth and nail.”
- Ampert’s death
-
This death was way too graphic to be put in a PG-13 movie, so it makes sense it wasn’t done exactly how it happened in the book. In the book, District 3 tribute and Beetee’s son, Ampert, is eaten alive by squirrel mutts. This scene in the book was absolutely grueling, and most knew it wouldn’t be fully shown in the movie. Instead, Ampert is still attacked by squirrels, but dies with a few wounds in Haymitch’s arms.
- Wellie’s Death
-
Another gruesome death dismissed as nothing. Wellie is the District 6 tribute who teams up with Haymitch. Wellie, Haymitch, and Silka are the only three left in the game. In the book, when Haymitch and Wellie split for a moment, Silka uses her axe and chops Wellie’s head clean off, holding it up to show Haymitch. For many reasons, this scene was not in the movie, but we didn’t even get to see Haymitch and Wellie bond as the last Newcomers in the game. Wellie was barely shown in the Games, even though her character and death were such an important part of Haymitch’s story.