For as long as I can remember, Thanksgiving has always been one of my least favorite holidays. Maybe that’s because it’s in the way of me getting to decorate for Christmas, or maybe it’s because I don’t like announcing my gratitudes for the world to hear. But most likely, it’s because of what everyone else loves about Thanksgiving: the food.
Yes, I can already hear the gasps of shock and disappointment, but it’s true- I do not enjoy Thanksgiving foods, not even mashed potatoes. The reason is simple on the surface; I am just a picky eater. However, to me it’s far more complicated. It’s not that I don’t want to like these foods, but my brain won’t let me enjoy them either, causing plenty of unpleasant Thanksgiving experiences.
Each year, one of my family members would ask me to try at least one new food during the feast, and I always dreaded it. I was perfectly happy with my meal of rolls, turkey, and a smattering of various desserts, however they were adamant about me broadening my horizons. And so, with a less than pleasant expression on my face, I would sample the smallest bit of whichever food they had asked me to try, and my reaction was always the same- a firm shake of my head, and a napkin to my tongue so I could scrape it away. You’d think after the first time it would be over, but this continued for many years and still happens sometimes today.
Is my reaction immature? Maybe, but there’s sort of a valid reason for it other than just not liking how things taste. My real issue is how they feel. For some reason, my taste buds do not enjoy the feeling of specific foods in my mouth, and ironically, they all correlate to Thanksgiving. Mashed potatoes, squash, gravy, cranberry sauce, and even my Nana’s carrots and turnips are all big nos in my book simply because my mouth can’t process them. While these foods are all pretty different in terms of taste (and texture depending on how your family serves them), each of them feels wrong to my taste buds. More specifically, they feel like mushy nightmares I can’t bear to swallow.
Considering that the entirety of my family’s Thanksgiving menu is categorized as mush to my taste buds and senses, my plate always looks sparse compared to everyone else’s. Rather than piling on the vegetables like everyone else, I stick to my safe foods of turkey and rolls. Sure, it’s not the most balanced meal, but they’re safe according to my sense of taste; they’re soft, solid, and have no trace of mushiness for me to grapple with.
However, despite my safe options of turkey and bread, I’m proud to share that I have expanded my horizons to stuffing within the past few years. While I acknowledge that some recipes for stuffing do cause mushy textures, the recipe we use each year causes a thick and dense version of the dish, which is fantastic for me and my sparse-looking plate each year.
Despite the turkey, rolls, and recent addition of stuffing, I can’t say that Thanksgiving has a particularly appetizing menu to my tastes, and there really isn’t much I can do to fix that other than eat what I like and fill up on dessert. However, if there are any picky eaters like myself reading this, know that your Thanksgiving plate of solid, dry foods and an array of desserts is more than welcome at my table