Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
South Carolina | Life > Experiences

Navigating Controversial Conversations at Thanksgiving Dinner

Reagan Michael Student Contributor, University of South Carolina
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at South Carolina chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

We’ve all heard the trope: you sit down for a holiday dinner and start small talk. Before you know it, someone makes a controversial comment and an intense argument breaks out across the turkey and fixings. When a family member says something offensive, ignorant, or inflammatory, it’s hard not to jump in immediately, guns-a-blazing. But if you want to have a genuine dialogue, it’s important to stay as calm as possible. And trust me, I know this is easier said than done. 

First, assess the situation. Is this a conversation truly worth engaging in, or is it something you can let pass for the sake of family harmony? If you do decide to engage, speak with a steady, but confident tone. As non-condescendingly as you can, explain why their comment was harmful, and help them to correct their path of thought. If they get heated, keep your cool. Take a break and collect yourself before returning to the conversation. Let your family member know that you don’t want to fight with them, and you’d like to have a respectful dialogue. 

Ultimately, you cannot change the mind of someone who does not want to listen. If you’re going to engage, you have to know when to let it go for the sake of your own sanity. This does not mean to concede your argument by any means, but sometimes you have to choose your battles. 

There is a time to speak truth to power and a time to butter a hot roll. Knowing the difference is very important.

John DeVore

This is a situation I know all too well, and it’s very emotionally draining to navigate. It’s one thing to argue with just anyone, but it hits much harder when it’s your loved ones. It can also be extremely morally conflicting. You recognize that these are your family members who have always loved you, yet, at the same time, they hold such hateful and bigoted beliefs towards others. 

If I heard one of my peers say some of the things I’ve heard from my grandparents over the years, I would never want to spend time with them. Is it hypocritical to hold family members to a different standard? And if it is hypocritical, does that necessarily make it wrong? These are just some of the questions I ask myself when these situations arise, and there is no “right” answer to any of them.

It’s up to every individual to decide what their threshold is, and I would never encourage someone to keep a person in their life for the sole reason of blood relation. At the end of the day, protect your peace, and do what makes you feel the happiest with yourself. While progress can’t be made without dialogue with the other side, it’s not your burden to change the beliefs of your family members, especially when they refuse to listen to you.

Reagan Michael

South Carolina '27

Reagan Michael is the Editor-in-Chief of Her Campus at South Carolina.

Reagan is a Senior at the University of South Carolina studying Mass Communications. Reagan typically writes cultural and political articles, with a focus on social issues. Outside of Her Campus, Reagan is the Marketing Chair of UofSC's undergraduate student-run theatre organization, Ghost Light Productions.

Reagan enjoys spending time with friends and family, watching movies and TV shows, and playing with her cat, Sage!