It’s no secret that Ryan Murphy has become a staple pop culture figure over the years, and his creation, Glee, is no exception, often considered by many of his fans to be his magnum opus. However, all good things must come to an end, and the Glee two-hour series finale aired on Mar. 20, 2015.
When it launched in 2009, Glee was considered an extremely progressive coming-of-age comedy; it featured a highly diverse cast of “misfits,” and that visibility was rare, especially alongside steamy shows like The Vampire Diaries.
Nevertheless, over a decade later, the show that was hailed for its progressive storylines in 2009 and catchy musical performances is still gaining streams to this day, and has been followed by controversy over the last five years, with audiences deeming the show incredibly offensive and a show that had fallen into the trap of wanting to be inclusive but missing the mark so greatly.
As discussions of a potential Glee reboot spread and were eventually confirmed by Ryan Murphy himself, set to stream on Disney+ and Hulu, a question emerges. Is this reboot pointless, or does television’s landscape need this necessary evil?
A ‘Glee’ Reboot
Few television shows have had the cultural impact that Glee has, which is why, in one respect, rebooting the show takes away what made the original so special. It’s no secret that reboots and sequels have been getting less and less excitement from the general public, as audiences crave something new.
At the time, what made the original series stand out wasn’t just the incredible musical performances but the chemistry of the cast and characters. Replacing these characters with new ones under the same title could feel less like a reboot and more like the show trying to capitalize on the original’s nostalgia.
Additionally, although Glee has had a large cultural impact, it’s also received considerable criticism over the years. The show aired in a very different cultural climate from today, but it sparked uncomfortable conversations about race, sexuality, and religion. Those conversations haven’t always aged well, but some storylines have been praised for their representation at a time when representation wasn’t the norm.
A show with offensive storylines from the 2010s, you’d think, would be hated in today’s climate. Still, its clever writing and hysterical satirical comedy have made it a beloved series for the current generation, but part of what makes Glee a cultural staple and cult classic is how different it was from today’s cultural climate. A reboot that recreates the same formula with updated musical performances wouldn’t justify its existence.
A Necessary Evil
While a reboot can seem unnecessary, it can also be a necessary evil. I refer to this reboot as a necessary evil because the original Glee has retained a somewhat cult-classic status on television due to its offensive yet simultaneously progressive humor. It’s something audiences have said “couldn’t be made today,” yet it’s still so loved.
Part of the show’s major storylines throughout the seasons is that the group of students the show is centered on is constantly getting bullied by the jocks and cheerleaders. This was a show where bullying was a central theme throughout the seasons, and that regardless of your gender, race, or sexuality, bullying you because of that won’t change who you are.
Now, in 2026, social media is part of our culture. Students use social media to connect, but they also bully other students for being different. A Glee reboot could explore the themes of bullying in the original series while updating these themes for modern audiences. It can retain the same lessons but modernize them for a new audience entrenched in day-to-day use of social media and show how bullying through social media doesn’t define who you are, continuing the lessons and themes of the original series.
Ultimately, a Glee reboot would be necessary if it were written with something to say rather than banking on nostalgia bait. The question is whether the show needs a reboot, whether this generation is ready for a show like Glee, and whether this reboot becomes an unnecessary curtain call.
Want to see more HCFSU? Be sure to follow us on Instagram, Twitter, YouTube, and Pinterest!