Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
U Conn | Culture > Entertainment

Are Boy Bands Obsolete?

Lily Doyle Student Contributor, University of Connecticut
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at U Conn chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

I remember, as a young girl, my older sister used to have a One Direction poster above her bed. It was a little wrinkled and had folds vertically and horizontally alluding to the fact that it probably came as a bonus to the purchase of a CD. I remember that it was an early poster of them. One from when they first got together, shortly after their X-Factor appearance. I guess this classified my sister as a “OG” fan, the evidence being solely in the poster. What I thought was a special touch was the additional poster of a solo Harry Styles, however this touch is anything but special. So many teenage girls shared this commonality with my sister that it could probably be considered universal. I don’t think I need to explain why — it is Harry Styles after all. However, Styles wasn’t the only reason One Direction was so popular. 

One Direction as a whole was a record-setting group that dominated teenage girls’ hearts across the globe. Their most notable tracks had billions of streams across digital platforms, their tours ranked as some of the highest-grossing concert tours for a vocal group, and they were the first group in history to have their first four albums debut at No. 1 on the U.S. billboard 200 chart. Their impact globally and culturally can’t be understated. And while I was still young, I distinctly remember the destruction and carnage that occurred when Zayn left and the band went on “hiatus” shortly after. I know I’m picking on One Direction, but the truth is that there were many boy bands that stole the hearts of girls from the 90s to the 2010s. I mean who wouldn’t adore attractive guys singing and dancing about romance, breakups, and apologies? 

But as I was reminiscing about my sister’s poster, I realized that if we look at pop culture currently, boy bands are nowhere to be seen. I mean we have a few girl groups, like KATSEYE, and we have so many solo acts, but boy bands are nowhere near the level of popularity they were a couple decades ago. So, what happened to them? Is society officially leaving boy band heartthrobs in the dust?

One of the main reasons why boy bands aren’t as popular as they once were is probably because they have all broken up. Boy bands used to make their success by singing about relationship break ups, but I think a more pressing issue is that all of these boys are breaking up with each other. I mean, every time a boy band goes on an indefinite hiatus, the media writes stories of their burnout and addiction and mental health struggles. Which are all valid reasons for a boy band to break up, but it’s also informing the public and aspiring bands that it’s not worth it, especially when these are the consistent consequences to forming a boy band. It’s an obvious cause and effect chain, these boy bands break up because of burnout, and no one steps up to the plate because they don’t want to suffer the same fate.

It also never helps that usually boy bands have one member who outshines the others. We see this through One Direction with Harry Styles, NSYNC with Justin Timberlake, Jonas Brothers with Nick Jonas, and the list goes on. And yes, this may be seen as a cliche, one member outshines the others and the other members get resentful and angry and all decide to break up, but cliches aren’t born out of thin air; they have examples to back them up. It’s a classic trope that exemplifies that desire to not suffer the same fate. It tells the public that it’s no use to become a boy band because you’re just going to break up anyways. The resentment that members can feel when they think they aren’t being treated fairly isn’t some folk tale, it’s real. And because every pop idol has to have some level of ego to them, they usually take this unfairness as a personal attack and boom, the band has disbanded. 

I’ve been talking a lot about burnout and how heavily it affects a band’s decision to break up, but why do boy bands have burnout in the first place? The answer stems from the lack of creative freedom boy bands usually have throughout their careers. Something that I think the public and media may not grasp completely is that boy bands are basically corporate employees. Rather than the artists who have creative and direct control of the music they produce and the image they present, it’s the record label that holds all of that power. A lot of the time, boy bands are thought of and assembled by producers before the actual members are even cast. When these members are officially cast, they face strict guidelines ruling over personal lives, public image, and most importantly the production of “their” music and lyrics. Since music is intrinsically creative, the restriction and authorization of lyrics, melodies, dynamics, and more can create heavy resentment within the band and towards higher-ups.

Now, I want to highlight a specific boy band/group that actually contrasts this idea: BTS. While K-Pop groups and Western boy bands are usually managed strictly through record labels, BTS actually co-writes and co-produces a majority of their discography. BTS’ record label, Big Hit Entertainment, worked closely with the K-Pop group to allow artistic autonomy, while still expecting precise and successful execution, contributing to the group’s global popularity. Additionally, another difference BTS holds from traditional boy bands is their ability to create solo projects while still remaining an active member. Many times, boy bands will split up in an effort to regain their loss of creative control and, in doing so, create a solo career. These actions are not necessary for BTS. They can freely move between individual musical paths and membership with BTS, instead of being a bird in a cage with no space to flap their wings.

A point I want to expand on lightly is the fact that a lot of boy bands are manufactured and created with a goal of money in mind. In other words, a lot of boy bands are inauthentic and artificial. In earlier decades, younger generations (the target audience for boy bands) were either unaware of this fact or didn’t care, but today, with the rise of AI, younger generations are leaving artificiality behind and prioritizing genuineness. With the prominence of artificial intelligence in day-to-day life, I’ve noticed that young adults are instead turning towards authenticity. Because of this, the corporate feel of a boy band isn’t going to win any points the way it might back in the 90s. If a boy band were to rise to fame with the same tactics as before, it would be likely that they wouldn’t succeed, solely because the mindset of their target audience has shifted. People are seeking human genuineness and candor, not corporate greed and phoniness. If boy bands want to succeed in today’s world, they would have to understand this: It isn’t cool to be fake. 

To reflect back on our original question: Is society leaving boy bands in the dust? I think the answer is a confident “maybe.” While we’ve found that society is leaving behind inauthenticity, which is a lot of boy bands’ foundation, we can’t ignore the fact that, even today, One Direction and other broken up boy bands hold cultural impact. I think it’s important to differentiate that boy bands who may be looking to form current day, might not get the success they want. However, boy bands from the past can still hold a piece of fangirls’ hearts, like how I’m sure One Direction is still in the heart of my sister. And while there isn’t an equivalent to One Direction, current day fangirls aren’t low on pop culture to consume either. There are thousands of solo artists who aren’t going anywhere and are creating a ton of media for fans to engage with. And even though I’ve been targeting boy bands throughout this piece, I would be happy to see one rise to fame in 2026. Regardless, it looks like the chapter has closed on boy bands for now.

Lily Doyle

U Conn '26

Lily is currently a first year animal science major at the University of Connecticut. She aspires to become an equine veterinarian after college. In Lily's free time, she enjoys reading (any genre), doing pilates and yoga, hanging out with friends, getting coffee, and overall having a good time.

Lily is originally from Billerica, Massachusetts and used to be involved in dance, theater, Women in Science and Engineering, National Honor Society, Science National Honor Society, Italian National Honor Society, and horseback riding.

At the University of Connecticut, Lily is involved in various clubs. Other than Her Campus, Lily is involved in Dairy Club and Block & Bridle.