Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
Northeastern | Culture

Can We See Everything?

Elizabeth Sergi Student Contributor, Northeastern University
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at Northeastern chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

Spoiler alert: The following article contains information about the plot of “You Can See Everything.”

I recently saw “You Can See Everything” in theaters and, much like everyone else, became instantly enamored. Co-directed by Lance Oppenheim and Nathan Fielder, the documentary follows Fielder as he lives in the guesthouse of Elizabeth Holmes’ California beachfront rental during the 34 days leading up to the start of her 11-year prison sentence. For those who do not know, Holmes, founder of Theranos, was convicted of defrauding investors in a scheme involving more than $140 million. She was ordered to pay $452 million in restitution alongside former Theranos executive Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani. The film documents the family’s every move, with cameras capturing an unusually intimate portrait of their lives. As its theatrical run winds down, the documentary has earned widespread acclaim, boasting a 97% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes and a $15.6 million opening weekend. However, the film’s success stems not only from its subject matter, but also from the unconventional structure through which it unfolds.

Unlike many traditional documentaries, Fielder took a three-act approach to “You Can See Everything.” The first act is closest to what one might expect from a project of this kind, following Fielder, Holmes and her fiancé, Billy Evans, during Holmes’ final days before her sentence begins. Throughout this portion, the audience starts to get a feel for both Holmes and Fielder, as well as their respective perspectives on the situation. Fielder initially serves purely as a documentarian, asking Holmes and Evans questions to better understand their viewpoints and Holmes’ perception of her time at Theranos. At one point, Fielder even declines Holmes’ invitation to swim with her in the ocean, explaining that it goes against his rules as a filmmaker (and that he hates cold water).

One of the most notable conversations between Holmes and Fielder occurs during this portion of the film, as they attempt to dissect Holmes’ claim that Theranos “can” run any test in the world. Fielder compares their convoluted discussion to the popular Abbott and Costello comedy sketch “Who’s on First?” Holmes and Fielder debate the meaning of the word “can,” eventually arriving at a tentative conclusion: Holmes meant Theranos was capable of running every test in the world, rather than that it could currently run every test. Evans then interjects, ending the conversation with the remark, “She just thinks differently.” The purpose of this first act is to win sympathy for Holmes, allowing the audience to see her beyond the Theranos persona. In a way, Fielder is leading the audience much like Holmes once misled investors. The first act ends with Holmes heading to prison and Fielder driving away.

The second segment of the documentary takes place two years later and opens with Evans and Holmes in the early stages of developing their new laser-health business, a sort of Theranos 2.0 in the making. However, with Holmes now in prison, Fielder faces a major barrier: The central subject of his documentary is no longer accessible. This is where the film begins to shift from traditional documentary filmmaking into something much more. Fielder brings in Amanda Seyfried, who portrayed Holmes in the popular series, “The Dropout,” to help him digest what he has learned about Holmes thus far. Seyfried now takes on a role similar to Fielder’s in the first act, trying to make sense of Holmes and her actions from an outsider’s perspective. Seyfried also reprises her role as Holmes, bringing to life the off-screen interactions Fielder had with Holmes and Evans.

The introduction of Seyfried is not only a creative way to continue the narrative but also feels distinctly on brand for Fielder. The second act challenges the audience’s perception of Holmes and Evans, prompting viewers to question their motives and distrust their intentions. Evans, in particular, appears increasingly villainous, with the film showcasing his controlling and volatile behavior in response to unfavorable situations. One stark example of Evans’ influence is that he holds power of attorney for Holmes while she is incarcerated. He also manages her X account, sometimes posting messages she sends him through email and at other times even publishing self-written posts without consulting her, raising questions about her digital autonomy. These revelations leave Fielder intensely eager to see Holmes face-to-face again, a difficult ask due to her imprisonment.

Part three, the shortest yet most impactful, opens with Fielder and Seyfried reading a script based on Fielder’s account of meeting with Holmes at her detention facility. As they read, they wrestle with the meaning of Holmes’ words and actions, much like in the second act, but this time their interpretations differ: where Seyfried sees deceit, Fielder sees authenticity. Curious about this shift in perspective, Seyfried asks whether Fielder left anything out of the scripts to protect Holmes. Although he denies it, the exchange leaves the audience with a sense of unease.

In the final minutes, footage captures Fielder and Holmes swimming together in the cold water at her beachfront home. It is one of the film’s most shocking moments, undermining the impression of professional distance created by Fielder’s earlier refusal to swim. By withholding this footage until the very end, the documentary forces viewers to recontextualize all preceding exchanges, giving greater weight to the question Seyfried raised: Was anything left out?

One of the first things I learned in my film production class is that all documentaries are inherently biased; the difference is that many do not depict themselves as such. The true genius of this film lies in Fielder’s decision to portray himself as a seemingly objective observer, only to gradually suggest that he may be an unreliable narrator. By challenging the perspective the audience has been led to adopt throughout the film, the documentary ultimately forces viewers to confront an uncomfortable question: How much of this is real? It deliberately manipulates the audience into distrusting everyone, including the filmmakers, leaving them to come to their own conclusions.

Even the title alludes to this idea, with a heavy focus on the word “can.” “You Can See Everything” suggests that we, the audience, have the ability to see everything, much like the Theranos device (allegedly) had the capability of running every test. But as proven, Theranos’ technology could not deliver on that promise. So, yes, we can see everything. But do we?

Elizabeth Sergi

Northeastern '27

Lizzie is a fourth year from Alexandria, VA. She's currently pursuing a degree at Northeastern in Marketing and International Business, with a Media Production minor and is applying to law school. Lizzie enjoys writing in her free time and uses Her Campus as a space to explore, educate, and connect with others through her topics.