“Fake it till you make it.”
A mentality that’s been pressed, packaged, and sold to us in all aspects of our everyday lives.
As university students, we see this happening a lot. Whether it’s surviving your classes, reading all of the material, or fabricating experiences on your resume. We are told to fake our entire being. Faking it is pushed as the only way to succeed.
Not only do tangible factors count in this illusion, but so does personality and creating a facade of confidence in yourself and your abilities.
This false confidence is deeply intertwined with capitalism. Almost as if it’s a prerequisite to “making it big” within the business world. The two work together in a logical sense. In order to make it big and gain maximum profits, one must persuade investors and customers of their confidence in the product being the best on the market.
In certain settings, this confidence falters. We see how online viewers often critique celebrities and influencers on this false confidence. Deceiving sponsorships and influencer brands are sliced out, operated on and observed until an issue destroys this confidence.
Yet, the pursuit of truth and a craving for justice has taken a hypocritical turn as people have begun to adopt a fascination with the “fake it till you make it” crimes.
A few years back in February of 2022, a Netflix mini series featuring Shonda Rimes gained a lot of traction. “Inventing Anna” followed a journalist’s investigation into Anna Delvey. Although it contained slight differences,the series recounts the general story of Anna “Delvey” Sorokin, criminal who posed as a German heiress and later became a New York socialite who scammed countless wealthy people. Her crimes of theft, although serious, were glamourized by the public due to her ability to get to the top by using her false confidence.
The fascination with “fake it till you make it” theft has recently spilled over onto the case of Elizabeth Holmes. This came after the release of Nathan Fielder’s documentary “You Can See Everything” showed him spending 34 days with her before her prison sentence.
Who is Elizabeth Holmes?
Holmes, the CEO and founder of Theranos Inc., started the company in 2003 at age 19 after abruptly dropping out of Stanford University’s electrical and chemical engineering program. During her time at Stanford, she had gained extensive experience and networking opportunities, observed her professors’ academic laboratories, and worked on medical diagnostic SARS chips. This ultimately led her to create Theranos, an amalgamation of these ideas.
Theranos was built on the foundational goal of making medical information accessible as well as making bodily autonomy a human right. Holmes claimed that she developed a machine which would run over a thousand medical tests through the use of blood from a single finger prick.
Painless and quick in its diagnostic systems, Theranos began to surge in attention and investments, leading to its public commercialization in general pharmacies, including Walgreens. The pathway into mainstream medicine and the possibility of high profits enticed investors as Holmes’ company rose to a $9 billion value before the discovery of its fraudulent activity.
Her machines which were said to run over a thousand tests were faulty and not finalized. They also produced unreliable and false results. This ultimately led to a ban on reproduction of results, receiving funding, and later, a trial for wire fraud.
Sympathy for the Scam
Looking purely at the facts on paper, there is no doubt that people would be quick to attack Elizabeth Holmes. She had not only defrauded investors, but she also placed the health and lives of the people receiving false results at risk. However, Fielder’s new documentary allowed for the public to humanize her and feel sympathy towards her.
Within the documentary, Holmes’ went rom being a billionaire CEO to a stressed mother losing valuable time with her children due to her prison sentence. This transition positioned her in a completely different light to the public. Throughout the documentary she begins to appear as an innocent, nurturing caregiver. The media being very forgiving towards her would possibly not have happened had she not taken on this noble and honourable role.
Holmes’ roles not only as a mother, but more importantly, as a woman thriving in her field, played a key role in the sympathetic perception she’s acquired. Being named the world’s youngest self-made female billionaire by Forbes Magazine acted as a huge stride towards gender equality and breaking the glass ceiling. However, Holmes’ physical behaviours and public perception are what people attribute to her successfully playing this male dominated system. Her “husky, authoritative voice”, and her lack of emotions during interviews played a major role.
This sympathy transfers over towards individuals who perceive her as the ultimate Silicon Valley victim. Silicon Valley is a region in the San Francisco Bay Area in California where various tech companies such as Apple, Google, and Meta, rose to fame. Companies in this sector were renowned for their success and for flaunting power and wealth. Silicon Valley is the leading promoter of the “fake it till you make it” mentality. Due to this, online discourse began questioning if Holmes followed the same logic that so many other Silicon Valley entrepreneurs did. And if so, then why is she the only one that’s received fines and backlash?
Although understanding various perspectives about a case of any kind is crucial to forming a final opinion, it is also crucial for individuals to take both fact and subjectivity into account.