A$AP Rocky is facing backlash over accusations that he stole, reworked, and published work as his own in his latest music video, “Shroom Clouds.” These accusations came after Rocky spoke with Complex about AI in the arts, calling it a “tool.” But can AI still be ethical if it’s used as a “tool” to steal from small creators?
The music video is set in a surreal, picturesque field and features a segment of him spinning through what appears to be a grassy tunnel. This tunnel draws a striking comparison to creative director Cache Bunny’s 2019 video series.
Cache Bunny’s response
Cache Bunny highlighted the similarities between his and Rocky’s music video in an Instagram story, saying he was disappointed. “They took our video without permission (or even asking), then fed it into AI and changed Jason to A$AP Rocky,” he explained. “They left our original grass and shadow intact, so this is indisputably stolen?”
In another Instagram story, Cache Bunny acknowledged the attention the situation has gotten and turned to followers for advice on how to handle it. “I’ve gotten over 600 messages about this so far. I don’t know what to do about it yet, but clearly this has struck a major chord with the creator community, which is nice to see. Stealing artists’ work is not ok, and that’s not the precedent we want to set. I can’t understand why they didn’t just reach out to license the clip, or make their own version inspired by it.” He posted, “If anyone has advice on what to do, please let me know.”
a$Ap Rocky’s stance on AI
A$AP Rocky just came off an interview with Complex where he addressed AI in creative spaces, saying he doesn’t feel in a position to determine how AI should be used in music; however, he tries to use it practically. “AI is supposed to be a tool in that sense. If somebody does a totally AI-generated song where all they did was prompt something, then I think that that’s their thing. But who am I to say what’s standard and what’s not? I’m just doing me out here, and I’m doing my music practically—the right way,” he said. His idea of the “right way” means some of the cosmetic details of producing music, not manufacturing lyrics.
Rocky’s team has since responded to the AI allegations, saying they reached out to the original creator and hope to provide proper attribution. “I have reached out directly to @cache_bunny to start a conversation and resolve this matter appropriately.” Gallardo said the team is “fully open to discussing proper attribution and potential collaboration whenever they are ready to connect.“
AI in art
Even after legislation stating that entirely AI-generated music cannot receive copyright protection, the merge between AI and creative spaces remains a gray area. The current mishandling of AI in Rocky’s music video and the theft of another creator’s work highlights the dangers of using something as unreliable as AI to create something as authentic as art.
A$AP Rocky’s team is working to handle the situation and acknowledges the mistake, marking a step forward. However, mistakes like this represent the dangers of using AI in art and why we should keep artificial tools out of spaces that are best performed by humans.