On September 10th, 2026, season five of the hit reality tv show The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives dropped with five brand new episodes. The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives follows a group of Mormon mothers and wives, “Momtok,” where they originally gained a platform on TikTok. Although each member of Momtok had their own respective platforms, what led them to being offered a reality show was due to the 2022 “soft swinging” scandal that Taylor Frankie-Paul was the face of. As expected, when this swinging scandal leaked it started a massive controversy that led to Taylor’s divorce with her husband Tate Paul, as well as other Momtok members such as Miranda Hope (formerly McWhorter) and her at the time husband, Chase McWhorter, initially denying the allegations leading to a fractured friendship between Taylor and Miranda. Shortly after the swinging scandal became public, filming for the pilot of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives began in early 2023 which covered the aftermath of the swinging scandal as well as the arrest of Taylor due to a domestic violence incident involving her boyfriend Dakota Mortensen. Due to the legal proceedings around the domestic violence incident, filming was halted for nearly a year and did not pick up again until early 2024. Throughout the course of season one we follow Taylor’s journey after the swinging scandal as well as her new found, whirlwind romance with Dakota Mortensen and the pregnancy that followed with that relationship. Despite the domestic violence incident, Taylor and Dakota eventually continued their relationship but it quickly turned sour when infidelity allegations came out regarding Dakota. Season one primarily followed the events of Taylor’s highly public and controversial scandals, and shows us her process of trying to move forward upon the birth of her and Dakota’s child.
Season two picks up in late 2024, seven months after season one filming wrapped. Season two follows Taylor in a different way than it did the season prior, and showcases her journey of moving forward, which includes her reconciliation with Miranda after she initially denied her involvement in the swinging scandal. We also see more of her relationship with Dakota and the aftermath of his involvement with another woman, which resulted in the end of their relationship. However, the emotional attachment between Taylor and Dakota remained, which became an important factor in later seasons. Overall, after season two aired and we were headed into season three Taylor’s public image turned around from her previous controversial scandals and many people considered her to have a “redemption arc.” By season three, Taylor’s arc had strayed away from the original 2022 swinging scandal and focused more on her on again off again dynamic with Dakota. Although Taylor does seem to be stuck in a cycle with Dakota three seasons later, season three explores her confronting these patterns and taking accountability for getting caught in the trap she does with Dakota, leading her to square one again. By the end of season three, Taylor remains in a mostly good public image and people are recognizing her efforts to be better and grow from her past experiences. However, by season four and five Taylor’s public image starts to shift again. Season four offered hope for many fans of Taylor when she was announced as the next Bachelorette, which many people saw as a way for her to finally move on from Dakota and grow as a person despite her past experiences. However, as we see in the show Taylor gets stuck in the trap with Dakota once again, and sleeps with him just days before leaving to film the Bachelorette, as well as directly after returning from filming when she was allegedly engaged to another man. This shifted Taylor’s public image again and many people began scrutinizing her heavily due to her reckless behavior in regards to her relationship with Dakota, and not doing the work to move on. This only worsened further when the domestic violence incident footage from 2023 between Taylor and Dakota resurfaced just weeks before her Bachelorette season was supposed to air, resulting in ABC pulling her season entirely. Overall, by the latest season of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Taylor wrecked her public image once again and essentially discredited the work she did in prior seasons by staying trapped in her cycle with Dakota as well as the mistreatment towards other members of Momtok who tried to intervene and help her out of these toxic patterns she has. After season five aired, Mikayla Matthews announced her exit from the show amid filming season six when Hulu did not pull Taylor Frankie-Paul despite her recent behavior. Taylor later quit filming for the sixth season. Overall, throughout the course of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives we see Taylor Frankie-Paul go on a roller coaster of a storyline, originally seeing her controversial relationships and domestic violence incident, and then redeeming herself by displaying growth only to end up being set back despite her opportunities to continue growing.Â