Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
UCLA | Culture > Entertainment

I Would Never Pretend Not to Know You: Did Daisy Edgar-Jones and Paul Mescal Really Create Casual?

Nathalia García Romand Student Contributor, University of California - Los Angeles
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at UCLA chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

Upon the worldwide release of the Sense and Sensibility film, the public’s attention has once again turned to the shining and promising star Daisy Edgar-Jones. Since her breakout role as Marianne Sheridan in the 2020 TV Show Normal People, this charming actress has consistently won over critics and audiences alike. Yet, what makes her stand out among the new, promising Hollywood stars is her particular dynamic with her co-star, Paul Mescal, who played Connell Waldron in the Normal People adaptation. Why is this connection so special? 

Well, Normal People is a TV show adapted from Sally Rooney’s novel that follows the complex and evolving dynamic between Marianne and Connell, two young lovers who consistently choose personal growth, independence, and separate futures over their relationship. Together, Daisy and Paul didn’t just portray a coming-of-age romance; they redefined how modern media captures the blurred, messy boundaries between love, friendship, and casual intimacy. And, funny enough, Daisy and Paul have shown the public that life truly imitates art.

Beyond the screen, the real-life connection between Daisy and Paul only deepened the public’s fascination. Normal People became a cultural phenomenon because of its raw, unvarnished look at young relationships. And when, years after its release, its two main co-stars remain in contact and have “more than casual” interactions under the public eye, one cannot help but wonder: was the dynamic between Paul and Daisy truly casual on set? I mean, if you’re able to confess to someone, “I would never pretend not to know you,” ‘”I’m not a religious person, but I do sometimes think God made you for me,” and “We could be in a room full of people, and my eyes would always meet yours, just to find that you have already been looking,” most people would definitely not be normal about it.

Friendships between men and women are real. But when people like Daisy and Paul, who have had multiple partners (such as Phoebe Bridgers, Gracie Abrams, and Ben Seed) over the last couple of years, and keep looking at, talking about, and admiring each other the way they do under the public eye, it doesn’t feel casual. Today, we tend to understand “casual” as a dynamic without labels, commitment, or expectations, while still allowing emotional and physical intimacy. In Daisy and Paul’s dynamic, we, as an audience, can label their connection as casual to protect them from public labels, yet we can also recognize that the profound emotional connection they share constantly defies that definition, proving that true intimacy is rarely simple or disposable.

Just like in Normal People, Daisy and Paul have demonstrated that true connection, whether romantic or platonic, is rarely casual, no matter what label you attach to it. Even when trying to maintain distance or pretend like their bond is as simple as that of regular coworkers, the weight of Paul and Daisy’s mutual recognition, just like in the quote “I would never pretend not to know you,” always pulls them back together. Their ability to genuinely show what it entails to know someone — and to refuse to pretend otherwise — is one of the most powerful acts of intimacy possible in our generation and those that follow.

Nathalia is a third-year Philosophy and Classical Civilization student at UCLA from Riverside, CA. She's in the Pre-Law track and is very passionate about reading, writing, films, cats, music, and Snoopy. You can find her walking around campus while listening to music and reading a new book!