Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
U Mass Amherst | Culture > Entertainment

Red Queen vs. Powerless, The “Uncanny” Similarities of Fantasy

Ankita Goswami Student Contributor, University of Massachusetts - Amherst
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at U Mass Amherst chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.


Disclaimer: Spoilers (Obviously)

Quick bias warning: I read Red Queen for the first time around 13 years old and absolutely ADORED it. That said, after hearing lots of praise for the Powerless series, buying the book, and letting it gather dust on my shelf for about two years, I finally sat down and binged the entire trilogy a few months ago.

I’ll preface this by saying I actually enjoyed the series! Characters Paedyn and Kai had some funny banter, some very romantic scenes, and parts of the plot felt original (I’ll dive more into that later). That being said, up until that point, it had been close to a decade since I had touched Red Queen, and I still, at various points throughout the series, would set down the book and be like, “Haven’t I read this before?” After a certain point, my longing for Red Queen had returned in full force, and that is why, after reading the entire Powerless trilogy, my next reading endeavor was rereading the entire Red Queen quartet back to back, and I documented every similarity I noticed.

As a huge fantasy lover, I get that certain tropes can get redundant (fairies, powers, werewolves, enemies to lovers, etc.). However, in my opinion, these specific plot points were too on the nose and contributed a HUGE amount to their respective plots. Also, just to get it out of the way, Red Queen came out in 2015, and Powerless came out in 2023, so no overlap in the time of their creation as far as I know. Both series revolve around oppression, with each series having one group in power, with literal powers (Silvers in Red Queen, and Elites in Powerless). In each series, there are also significant rebellions against said oppressors (Reds against Silvers in the Scarlet Guard, and Ordinaries against Elites in the Resistance). Mare and Paedyn are huge vantage points in their rebellions, due to their proximity to royalty.

Speaking of royalty, both monarchies consist of two half-brothers, and a sort of love triangle occurs in both books. In both books, the female protagonists are betrothed to the brother that they are not actually in love with, and are in fact in love with the other brother. Both Mare and Paedyn end up in a position where they have to lie about their identity and impersonate their oppressors (Mare pretends to be Silver, Paedyn pretends to be Elite). The brother that they are betrothed to ends up being a sort of evil, making the decision of which brother to pick fairly simple (and an extra disgusting detail is included in Powerless, which will be discussed), and finally, a double betrayal occurs in both books (Mare uses Cal for the scarlet guard, Cal chooses duty/kingdom over Mare, Paedyn kills Kai’s father and Kai kills Paedyn’s father). While the last one has different circumstances surrounding their respective betrayals, genuinely what are the odds?

Alongside the major plot points, there were a few coincidences that, while they didn’t have a huge hold on the plot, are still eerily similar. For example, both sets of lovers (the brother they truly love) bond over dance lessons. Additionally, their main trope can be boiled down to lovers to enemies back to lovers (due to the betrayals), and girls from a lower-class background suddenly thrust into a life of riches and privilege due to their significant others. Both books have a character with a scar down the side of their neck and below the collar (Farley in Red Queen, Paedyn in Powerless), and both Paedyn and Mare were given a horrible body mutation in the form of branding.

As I mentioned before, I did enjoy the Powerless series, and while a large part of that was most likely because I loved Red Queen, there were some original plot points that are worth briefly discussing. In Red Queen, Mare ends up actually being a rare combination of both the victim and the oppressor (has Red blood, but powers like a Silver). Paedyn is as she is, an Ordinary. Paedyn also has an incredibly complicated family tree, where it ends up that she and her betrothed are HALF-BROTHERS (ew!). Luckily, it ends up that the half-brothers are actually not biologically brothers at all, and so there are no further issues. The entirety of book 2 in the Powerless series involves Paedyn on the run from Kai, who was hunting her, which was not present in Red Queen, alongside trials where Paedyn had to prove her worth in books 1 and 3 that were pretty interesting. Finally, one of my favorite romance scenes was when Kai and Paedyn were in the poppy fields, making flower crowns for each other and finally confessing how they feel for each other. I won’t lie, it had me giddy. 

Ultimately, while I enjoyed Powerless for its romance and unique moments, its overwhelming similarities to Red Queen left me wondering where inspiration ends and imitation begins.

Can’t get enough of HC UMass Amherst? Be sure to follow us on Instagram, listen to us on Spotify, like us on Facebook, and read our latest Tweets!

Ankita Goswami

U Mass Amherst '27

My name is Ankita! I am a biomedical engineering major who loves writing.