Her Campus Logo Her Campus Logo
UPR | Life > Experiences

The 5 A.M. Girl Experiment: Productivity Or Delusion?

Karissa Ayala Fernández Student Contributor, University of Puerto Rico - Rio Piedras
This article is written by a student writer from the Her Campus at UPR chapter and does not reflect the views of Her Campus.

Scrolling through TikTok, it feels like everyone is waking up at 5 a.m. The video always looks the same. It’s soft lighting, quiet mornings, journaling, gym workouts (especially pilates), making coffee, planning the day — everything calm and put together. The whole routine seems productive yet, somehow, serene.  It makes waking up early look less like a struggle and more like a personality. So, I tried it. For five days, I followed the 5 a.m. routine that always shows up on my feed. Alarm at 5, gym, shower, get ready, go to university, stay productive, repeat. The kind of routine that looks peaceful online, but feels very different when your alarm actually goes off in the dark. 

On the first morning, the alarm sounded way louder than it should have. 5 a.m. hits different when it’s real. I remember checking my phone half asleep, trying to figure out if I really had to get up or if I could stay in bed altogether. For a second, I almost turned the alarm off. But I didn’t, because the whole point is to see if this routine actually works. 

Getting out of bed that early is not aesthetic. 

It’s cold, it’s quiet, and your brain feels like it’s asleep. 

Most days, I went straight to the gym after waking up. (Pilates is way too expensive.) And the gym at 5 a.m. is a different place. It’s shocking how full it is at that hour. I was expecting it to be almost empty, but was surprised with the opposite. Everybody there actually looked like they knew what they were doing. I felt productive, but also confused about why I was there that early. 

After the gym, I would go home, shower, get dressed for university, and go to class. On those mornings, I did feel more organized. I wasn’t rushing. I had time to get ready, time to eat, time to think. It felt like I had control over my day instead of the other way around. 

But, I was also tired. 

Not extremely tired, just enough to feel it all day. 

Sometimes I would be sitting in class, trying to pay attention, and my brain felt slower than usual. Like I was awake, but not fully there yet. I kept thinking about how early I woke up, like my body hadn’t caught up with the schedule. The routine only felt good when I actually slept enough the night before. The nights I went to bed early, waking up at 5 wasn’t that bad. I had more energy and my mood felt better. Those days felt exactly like the videos. 

But the nights I stayed up late, the routine didn’t feel inspiring at all; it just felt forced. And that made me realize something that the aesthetic videos never really show. 

Not everyone is built for mornings.

If you like studying at night, talking to friends late, or just being awake when everything is quiet, waking up at 5 feels like you’re fighting your own schedule. It doesn’t mean you’re lazy. It just means your energy works differently. 

Online, the 5 a.m. routine looks perfect. 

In real life, it depends on how much sleep you get. 

I also looked into what sleep research says, and most of it doesn’t say waking up early makes you more productive. Research seems to emphasize getting enough sleep and having a schedule that actually works with your body. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommends at least seven hours of sleep for adults, specifically focusing on productivity and daytime alertness. Which honestly made sense after doing this experiment, because waking up at 5AM wasn’t really the hard part. Going to sleep early enough for 5 a.m. to actually feel good was. If you wake up at 5 but only sleep for five hours, you’re not disciplined — you’re just tired earlier. 

That honestly explained my whole week. 

Some mornings felt great. 

Some mornings felt like a mistake. 

Most mornings felt somewhere in between. 

The routine didn’t change my life. But, it did make me notice how much of productivity online is about how things look, not how they actually feel. Waking up at 5 can be peaceful. It can also feel exhausting. I think the difference isn’t the time on the clock; it’s whether the routine actually fits your life. 

Karissa N. Ayala Fernández is a writer for Her Campus, where she creates content that connects with college students through topics like lifestyle, self-expression, and everyday experiences. Her writing focuses on sharing relatable perspectives while keeping up with current trends, allowing her to produce pieces that feel both authentic and engaging.

Beyond Her Campus, Karissa is the founder of a small business specializing in crochet clothing, where she designs and creates unique, handmade pieces. This experience has strengthened her creativity, attention to detail, and understanding of branding. She is currently a student at the University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras, majoring in Public Relations and Publicity, where she continues to develop her skills in communication and media.

In her free time, Karissa loves crocheting, watching shows, reading, going to the beach, and keeping up with fashion. She’s really into how fashion can show personality and vibe, which also inspires both her writing and her designs. Most of the time, you can find her working on a new crochet piece, watching her favorite shows, or just enjoying a beach day.