This piece was submitted by Dhruv Maheshwari as part of Rewrite the Ending, a creative competition that invited participants to reimagine the endings of books, films and other familiar stories. Writers were encouraged to look beyond the original conclusion and explore how the story could unfold differently based on their own perspectives, real-world circumstances, or the ending they believed the characters deserved. The piece below is the author’s personal reinterpretation of the original narrative, presented as a creative exploration of alternative possibilities.
The Midnight Visitor by Robert Arthur
The night held its breath.
Max stood at the window, his silhouette carved against the Paris skyline, the gun still warm in his hand. Below, twelve feet down, lay the narrow ledge Ausable had described: calmly, matter-of-factly, as though ledges outside hotel windows were the most ordinary thing in the world. The kind of detail a man mentions because it is simply true.
“The police will be here in moments,” Ausable said, from behind him. “I suggest you go.”
Max looked at the window. Then at Ausable. Then at Fowler, who stood very still by the door, his face the colour of old paper.
Then Max stepped over the sill.
There was no ledge.
There had never been a ledge.
The sound he made on the way down was brief, and final, and quickly swallowed by the city.
Ausable straightened his jacket. Fowler stared at the open window for a long moment. At the curtain drifting inward, at the Paris night beyond, at the particular shape of a world in which a man could simply cease to exist between one breath and the next.
“That,” said Ausable, pouring himself a drink, “is how it is done.”
Cut to: CINEMA HALL, ‘The Midnight Visitor- Screenplay’
Row G, seats 14 and 15.
Riya was eating popcorn. Not watching the screen, eating popcorn at the screen, which is a different thing entirely. Her eyes were aimed roughly in the direction of the film but her attention was focused, with the full force of her considerable personality, on the boy sitting next to her.
His name was Arjun. He had suggested this film. He was now deeply regretting this film.
On screen, a British man in a suit was saying something about a ledge.
“Do you want some?” Riya asked, tilting the popcorn bucket toward him.
“Shh,” said the elderly couple in row F.
“Sorry,” said Arjun, to the elderly couple. Then, quietly, to Riya: “Yes.”
Their hands met in the bucket at the same moment. Neither of them pulled away.
On screen, a man fell out of a window and died.
“I don’t think I like spy movies,” Riya said.
“Me neither,” said Arjun. He had chosen this film very carefully. He had read three reviews. He did not say this.
“What kind of movies do you like?” she asked.
“Ones where people don’t fall out of windows.”
She laughed. Not a polite laugh, a real one, the kind that escapes before you can stop it. Arjun felt something in his chest that was entirely unrelated to the geopolitical thriller currently unfolding on the screen before them.
On screen, Ausable was explaining to Fowler, in measured tones, that the secret document had been secured, that the agency was safe, that the threat had been neutralised. Fowler nodded gravely. Years of training. Decades of experience. The entire fate of the Western world, resting on this moment.
“Do you want to leave?” Arjun asked.
Riya considered this for approximately half a second.
“Yes,” she said.
They gathered their things with the focused efficiency of people who have made a decision and are committed to it. Riya’s dupatta caught on the armrest. Arjun untangled it. Their faces were very close together for a moment.
On screen, Ausable raised his glass. A toast to the mission. To survival. To the particular grace required to watch a man die and then pour yourself a drink.
Riya and Arjun did not see this. They were already in the aisle.
The door swung shut behind them.
On screen, Fowler finally exhaled. three hours of tension releasing in a single breath, his whole body understanding at last that it was over, that they had made it, that the world would continue.
The elderly couple in row F watched until the credits rolled.
They had liked the film very much.
My Note.
The original ending of ‘The Midnight Visitor’ is almost uncomfortable in how clean it is. A man dies. Ausable pours a drink. Fowler is speechless. Robert Arthur gives you no time to process it, and that abruptness, I think, is the whole point. The story is about how espionage works: efficient, unsentimental, slightly absurd if you look at it long enough.
I wanted to push that absurdity to its logical extreme.
The zoom-out is the joke, but it is also the argument. We treat these high-stakes narratives as though they are the centre of the universe, as though the fate of the Western world is the only thing happening in any given room. But cinema has always known the truth: somewhere in row G, two people are sharing popcorn and not watching the screen at all. Life, romantic and mundane and completely indifferent to geopolitics, is always running parallel to the thriller.
Max falls. Ausable toasts. And Riya’s dupatta gets caught on an armrest.
Both things are equally real. One of them will be remembered longer.
The elderly couple staying till the credits was for the story. Someone always means it.
For more such articles, visit Her Campus at MUJ. And if you’d ever like to participate in our creative competitions, don’t forget to follow us on Instagram!