There's some truth to the famous saying that all of the best guys are either taken or gay; and when it comes to checking them out, I feel the same way I do about beautiful, overpriced handbags: there's no harm in looking...
I dare you to see Jonathan in Spring Awakening and not have your own Groff-induced awakening. Even a quick YouTube search of Jonathan playing opposite Lea Michele will do.
He's no Justin Timberlake, but Lance was a member of a boy band in the 90s which automatically earns him a spot on our list! We faced collective disappointment when Lance bravely came out and destroyed our fifth grade fantasy of marrying all of the members of ‘N Sync in one beautiful, beach ceremony (I mean...what?).
Oprah reference, anyone? On the off chance you didn't spend your high school career with a box of Bagel Bites on the couch every weeknight at 4:00, Nate Berkus is Oprah's go-to decorator/interior designer/heartthrob. He's gay, but I'll never fully accept the fact that we'll never grow old together. In a chic, sensibly designed home, of course.