BUY IT NOW OR CRY LATER: Skincare, Bath Robes & More Cozy Fall Essentials

This is a sponsored feature. All opinions are 100% our own.

Meet Buy It Now, Or Cry Later, our monthly roundup of cute, chic, funny, or just truly essential things our editors are buying right now. Because we like to shop, and you like to shop, so let's shop together, shall we? RIP to our bank accounts. This time around, enjoy our special fall favorites edition.


  1. 1. Kiehl’s Ultra Facial Cream

    Kiehl's,, $32; shop now

    This lightweight moisturizer is the one skincare product I can’t live without. It always leaves my skin feeling softer, smoother and visibly healthier. It provides just the right amount of hydration to keep my skin moisturized and balanced. I use this product morning and night, and my skin has never felt better. - Madeleine

  2. 2. Kiehl’s Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado

    Kiehl's,, $32; shop now

    I have sensitive skin, so I’m extra careful when it comes to choosing new products. But a friend recommended that I try this Avocado Eye Cream, and I have used it basically every morning since. It de-puffs and brightens your under eyes while leaving them feeling hydrated all day.  Plus the product is paraben-free and dermatologist-tested for safety. - Madeleine

  3. 3. Kimono Robe

    Nune,, $95; shop now

    You know that post-shower feeling? The one when the weather starts to get cold and humidity clings to your skin, leaving you overheated if you bundle up too quickly after? No? Well maybe there's something wrong with me, but cold szn = robe szn. And this colorful robe from Nuno is my absolute favorite! It's made out of recycled plastic bottles but it feels like silk, allowing me proper time to cool off from a scalding shower before jumping into my fuzzy jams. Plus, it embodies my love of every single lipstick in existence, but if you're looking for something a little more subtle, it does come in black as well! - Sammi

  4. 4. Velvet Noir Major Volume Mascara

    Marc Jacobs Beauty,, $27; shop now

    No matter how many other mascaras I try, I keep coming back to this guy. It has the perfect application and actually coats each and every lash. My favorite part is that it gives a full *and* curled look to the lashes, without weighing them down at all. It's the absolute best. - Maddie  

  5. 5. Soft Pinch Liquid Blush

    Rare Beauty,, $20; shop now

    It has been endlessly fun to play with the new products from Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez. In a move that’s extremely on brand for me, the liquid blush radiant finish has stolen my heart. The formula makes my cheeks so glowy and naturally flushed, and sometimes I use it on my lips and eyes too. If you haven’t tried Rare Beauty yet, I also recommend the With Gratitude Dewy Lip Balm and Positive Light Liquid Luminizer Highlight! - Gina  

  6. 6. Fall Nail Polish

    Essie,, $9; shop now

    The Fall 2020 collection of Essie nail polishes is something I wait all year for — no, seriously. They are always the best colors and this year is no exception. The beautiful burgundy shade, Swing of Things, is the epitome of fall and I simply cannot get enough. Catch me wearing this color until December 1. - Maddie

  7. 7. Talk Turkey Nail Polish Strips

    Color Street,, $13; shop now

    The first thing you need to know about me is that I’m terrible at nail art. Enter: these pre-painted nail polish strips that I can stick on my fingers instead of fussing over with lacquer and top-coat. I’m super into these festive designs for this season! - Gina  

  8. 8. Social Dog Blend - Coffee Bag

    Chamberlain Coffee,, $20; shop now

    WFH means I’m brewing my own coffee every day and experimenting with bev flavors to try and recreate Starbucks in my kitchen. The Social Dog Blend, a new coffee bag launch by Emma Chamberlain, just hits the flavor sweet spot for me. It’s got some milk chocolate and peanut butter smoothness in there that make this coffee taste way more expensive than it actually is. - Gina  

  9. 9. Everlasting Bouquet - All the Neutrals

    Pickletown Flower Co.,, $40; shop now

    Maybe I'm just imagining it (I have no green thumb), but flowers just don't last as long outside of the bright summer sun. Pickletown Flower Co. sells beautiful dried bouquets, so you don't have to worry about snipping stems or swapping out water and nutrients! This neutral bouquet is the perfect match for fall, no maintenance required. - Sammi