College Beauty Awards: All the Eye & Lip Makeup College Women Are Obsessed With

This is a sponsored feature. All opinions are 100% our own.

During our high school years, makeup options felt limited. Maybe your parents didn’t let you wear mascara till a certain age, or you didn’t have the budget to splurge on that trending eyeshadow palette. But in college, anything is possible in the beauty aisle. Makeup is supposed to accentuate what you’ve already got goin’ on, and that couldn’t be truer when talking about the best products for eyes and lips. Gels, pencils, liners, shadows, mascaras, glosses, balms – they let you enhance and play for a look-at-me moment, or they cover and refresh after that all-night study session.

So, whether you’re a winged-liner first-timer, or you’re just on the hunt for a new cult fave, we’ve rounded up the most beloved eye and lip products every college student should know about.

  1. 1. Stay Put Brow Color

    Milani, walmart.com, $8; shop now

    This brow pomade stays out for 16 hours of wear time, which is like everything, because your brows look perfect from day to night. The dual-ended brush also offers incredible brow color and definition at the intensity you want, so you can wear as sleek or fluffy depending on your brow style.

  2. 2. Brow Wiz

    Anastasia Beverly Hills, sephora.com, $21; shop now

    If you have over-tweezed brows, or arches in desperate need of some shaping, this ultra-slim brow pencil is perfect for adding lots of fine strokes that look like real hair.

  3. 3. Gimme Brow + Volumizing Eyebrow Gel

    Benefit Cosmetics, ulta.com, $24; shop now

    Thick and fluffy brows are in across the board, and this gel is a holy grail if thickness and tint are your priorities. We also have to give a round of applause for this tiny, easy-to-use brush.

  4. 4. High Brow Highlight & Lift Pencil

    Benefit Cosmetics, ulta.com, $22; shop now

    Sometimes, your look just needs a lift. This universal pencil blends away stray hairs and defines arches to keep your brows sharp.

  5. 5. Highliner Gel Eye Crayon

    Marc Jacobs Beauty, sephora.com, $25; shop now

    The shade range for this liner is incredible — so whether you’re feeling a jet black or teal glitter finish, this has a smooth glide and serious color payoff.

  6. 6. Stay Put Eyeliner

    Milani, ulta.com, $9; shop now

    This gel eyeliner formula has hyper-pigmented color and glides on so smoothly you only need to use one stroke, without any tugging and pulling on the eyelid. Use the smudger when you want a softer, diffused look. Too, the liner is mechanical and has a built-in sharpened to keep the pencil defined — one less item needed in your dorm!

  7. 7. Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

    Stila, sephora.com, $22; shop now

    This waterproof formula lasts, and it’s a great liner for beginners who still rely on the thin, marker tip.

  8. 8. Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner

    Bobbi Brown, sephora.com, $27; shop now

    If you’re desperate for a soft-liner look, this brow gel is for you. Drag on with a brush for total control, from a pigmented cat-eye, or close-to-the-lid line.

  9. 9. Gilded Rouge Eyeshadow Palette

    Milani, ulta.com, $20; shop now

    With foils, mattes and shimmers all in one palette, the possibilities are endless. This palette is all about glamour and drama in your everyday look, and we love to play with bendable, buildable and hyper-pigmented colors to create different moods.

  10. 10. Sweet Peach Eyeshadow Palette

    Too Faced, sephora.com, $49; shop now

    Pinks, corals, bronzes, purples – this palette has shades that are so versatile whatever your makeup look, and it’s beloved by college women everywhere. The juicy scent is just a bonus!

  11. 11. Tartelette 2 in Bloom Clay Eyeshadow Palette

    Tarte, ulta.com, $39; shop now

    This cult-fave has all the champagnes, browns, and coppers needed for everyday makeup. It’s truly an essential to have in your beauty arsenal.

  12. 12. Super Shock Shadow

    Colourpop, ulta.com, $6; shop now

    Every shade of this shadow is as playful and pigmented as the last. It’s a fan favorite for easy swipe-on and sheer glitter.

  13. 13. Melted Chrome Eyeshadow

    Essence, ulta.com, $5; shop now

    This glitter shadow is buttery and soft to touch, and it adds sparkle, but not in an over the top way. The eyeshadow is overall eye-enhancing, and you can purchase a few or all the shades for a metallic collection.

  14. 14. Voluminous Lash Primer

    L'Oréal Paris, ulta.com, $9; shop now

    Lash primer maximizes your mascara, and this one from L'Oréal is king for lengthening and volumizing your lashes.

  15. 15. Subversion Lash Primer

    Urban Decay, sephora.com, $22; shop now

    Sometimes all the goop we pile on our eyes can leave lashes dry and in need of some TLC. This primer is like a protective conditioner for your lashes, to keep them looking silky smooth and strong under your mascara.

  16. 16. Voluminous Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara

    L'Oréal Paris, ulta.com, $10; shop now

    Not only is this formula volumizing like no other, the brush bristles help create the loveliest fringe for clump-free lashes.

  17. 17. Worth the Hype Mascara

    NYX, target.com, $5; shop now

    We can’t help but stan a lengthening mascara that comes in pops of blue and purple color, in addition to the classic black.

  18. 18. Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara

    Tarte, ulta.com, $23; shop now

    This formula lengthens, volumizes, and defines — but most importantly, it adds a serious curl. For those with slick-straight lashes, meet your new hero mascara.

  19. 19. Keep It Full Nourishing Lip Plumper

    Milani, target.com, $20; shop now

    In case you missed the news, lips need volume too. Enter this luxe gloss that works like a two-in-one; it’s packed hyaluronic acid to nourish and moisturize over time, while peptides stimulate collagen to help fill lips to perfection. And there’s no uncomfortable burn that you get with other plumpers – instead just a delightful cooling effect.

  20. 20. Retro Matte Lipstick

    MAC Cosmetics, maccosmetics.com, $19; shop now

    For college women looking to make a statement, this lipstick is iconic for the bold and true range of colors — specifically Ruby Woo, a universal red.

  21. 21. SuperStay Matte Ink Lip Color

    Maybelline, ulta.com, $4; shop now

    A long-lasting matte is a girl’s best friend. We can't stop wearing this intense saturated formula (that comes in 20+ colors, btw) because it lasts all day and beyond.

  22. 22. Fleshy Lips

    Flesh Beauty, ulta.com, $18; shop now

    If no-makeup makeup is your thing, this lightweight formula adds a dewy pigment to your lips, but in the most natural-looking way.

  23. 23. Butter Lip Gloss

    NYX, target.com, $4; shop now

    True to its name, this creamy gloss is the perfect sheer lip enhancer for when you need something fast and vibrant to keep in your backpack for beauty touchups on the fly.

  24. 24. ColorStay Lip Liner

    Revlon, target.com, $6; shop now

    Lip liner adds definition and prevents your lip color from bleeding throughout the day. Add this to your makeup routine for a little more oomph than just a lipstick can provide on its own.

  25. 25. Powerplump Lip Balm

    Buxom, sephora.com, $18; shop now

    This balm feels tingly and adds a popsicle-stain hint of color. It's honestly magic, that's all we can say. 

  26. 26. Beeswax Lip Balm

    Burt’s Bees, target.com, $6; shop now

    This tint-free lip balm provides the ultimate daily nourishment your lips need to stay soft. Add a few extra coats when your lips are dry to revitalize the skin completely.

The Her Campus National Editors write about products we love and think you'll love too. Her Campus has affiliate partnerships, so we get a share of the revenue from your purchase.